
What we're taught about marriage shapes who we date (and what we put up with). Can we talk about it?
Some of you might know me from the Christian marriage sub, where I've posted more times than I'd like to admit (thank you to anyone who's been there, some of those comments got me through some really long, dark nights). I've also posted here quite a bite whenever I see someone asking about an abusive or addicted boyfriend or fiance (i'm the one usually waving the large, red flag and screaming into a megaphone) I'm posting here because I think this conversation needs to happen before the wedding, not after.
My situation has had me deep in Scripture, not looking to hate on marriage (I love love and I love marriage, which is why this hurts so much), but trying to understand how we as the church ended up where we are when it comes to marriages with abuse, addiction, and serious sin that isn't being repented of. And I've realized a lot of it starts way earlier than marriage. It starts with what we absorb while we're single.
When I was dating, shared faith was basically my main filter. If he loved Jesus and went to church, that was solid. I wish someone had told me that dating is for data, not just for getting to the altar.
Here's the theology I think a lot of us soak up without realizing it:
- your suffering is redemptive. endure long enough and your spouse will be "won over" (usually leaning on 1 Peter 3:1)
- your silence and peacefulness can be spiritual. don't always name what they're doing, just pray life into them (this was literally said to me during prayer at church today...)
- the marriage is what God wants preserved, so do everything to fix it
If you believe those things going into marriage, it changes how you date. You overlook stuff. You tell yourself love and prayer will fix it later. You feel like noticing red flags is unspiritual.
But the same chapter of 1 Peter literally says Christ "suffered once for sins" (3:18). Hebrews 10 says His sacrifice was once for all. Jesus puts rebuke BEFORE forgiveness and repentance before restoration (Luke 17:3). God calls himself slow to anger and then in the very next breath says he does not leave the guilty unpunished (Exodus 34:6-7). And Ephesians 5, the passage everyone uses to keep wives in there place, is the one that tells the husband to lay down his life.
Marriage is sacred because it points to Christ and the church. If a marriage needs one spouse to be sacrificed to keep it standing, its stopped pointing to Christ.
And I'm not anti-restoration at all. My parents have been counseling couples back together for like 20+ years and I've seen it happen. But every single one of those stories has the same thing in common: somebody repented. Restoration without repentance isn't really restoration.
So I'm curious what you all think:
- did your church or family teach you anything (directly or not) that made you feel like you had to stay or "fix" someone?
- what are the things beyond "is he/she a Christian" that you actually look for now?
- how do you tell the difference between normal relationship struggles and real red flags, especially when someone talks the faith talk really well?
I wrote a much longer version (Jephthah's daughter, Hosea, what I'd want pastors to hear) here if anyone wants it: https://notesfromthemend.substack.com/p/a-false-theology-for-the-abused