Do we think Sam had it with him through everything? 11x20
11x20. The necklace Dean threw away in season 5 glows in Sam's pocket. The implication being that he's kept track of it for 6-7 years. And Dean didn't find it with Sam's stuff after he fell into Hell and start wearing it, so maybe it was on his person. Like Sam had his brother's necklace with him in Hell. At least while he still had his body. I could write a fanfiction about that....
Also I'm not talking about the out of universe reasons for anything. I know the reason Dean didn't find it with Sam's stuff is because Jensen Ackles was absolutely sick of thing during fight scenes. I know the writers forgot about the necklace until the moment it became important and then it was suddenly in Sam's pocket for the cool scene. I know I'm thinking too deeply here but it's fun.
Idk, the implication that Sam has been carrying it around all this time is really interesting because they haven't both been on Earth the whole time. But for stuff like their guns, it makes sense because they obviously keep each other's stuff in the car for when they get back. But the only time Sam physically left this plane of existence since Dean chucked the thing, he didn't take anything with him.
I know there's the interpretation that Chuck put it Sam's pocket to create the moment, and that's certainly a very meta take to have. Because that is basically what the writers did. But I'm not sure which take is more common. Do you think Chuck put it in his pocket, or do you think Sam has been holding onto it?