u/Weekly-Dog-6838

Found on r/beyblade below a post asking about if 2 parts would be good together, despite them being incompatible since both are themselves a fusion of 2 normal parts

After 6 days, Pecharunt has finally been banished for its crimes against Kitakami and Ogrepon. Who’s out next? Comment your vote, most votes in ≈24 hours is out!

If you think something’s missing/wonder why one of the ones here is here, refer to the day 1 post, it’s probably explained there

Who’s out next? Comment your vote, most votes in ≈24 hours is out!

If you think something’s missing/wonder why one of the ones here is here, refer to the day 1 post, it’s probably explained there

Comment your vote for who’s out next, most votes in ≈24 hours is eliminated!

Note that this is a poll for Pokemon based on food, not edible Pokemon, and only fully evolved ones count. For more specifics see my day 1 post. Also, the numbers on each X is the order in which they’ve been eliminated

Veluza has filleted away to nothing! Vote for the one you like least, most votes in ≈24 hours is out! If you think something is missing/shouldn’t be here, check my comment for a link to day one, where everything on this list is explained.

Hey, I’m back! Sorry to everyone who voted in yesterday’s post, but those votes won’t count to this one since there’s so many more added now and Blissey is gone (for those curious, the winner was Slurpuff). As for why I’m doing day one over, it’s primarily because I forgot a lot of food Pokémon and didn’t really understand exactly what I was qualifying this based on myself. But after thinking on it a lot, I’ve refined my definitions down to this:

It must be fully evolved, and primarily or at least quite largely inspired by something that is clearly a food dish to count.

With all that being said, vote for 1 Pokemon to eliminate, most votes in 24 hours is out!

Some honorable mentions that didn’t quite make it:
-several people brought up Magikarp and Slowpoke or some others as animals that have canonically been eaten, but they are designed to be animals, not inherently food. I decided that the part that is eaten must itself already be based on a real food if it is canonically eaten, so we don’t go down a whole rabbit hole of which Pokémon can and can’t be eaten or at what point the claw on a living crab becomes a crab claw, the dish, for example.
-Miltank makes milk, but so do so many other mammals IRL and that’s another huge rabbit hole, so I’ll say that anything produced by several IRL animals as an aspect of reproduction will not be considered
-Blissey was here before, and came the closest of these to being here again, since it is indeed based around holding a food that is canonically eaten. But according to its BW Pokedex entry, these eggs are just eggs it lays, as every other Pokemon does, so the same logic as Miltank applies. Furthermore, beyond the egg pouch, it doesn’t really look like an egg or any other food. I can definitely understand if you thought it should be here, but between both of these factors against it I decided I didn’t want it.
-I debated both of the Exeggutors probably more frequently than any other one, but in the end, I decided it’s also not good enough. It’s a palm tree with coconuts for heads, but it’s more tree than coconut and honestly might pull from some other tropical trees more than coconut trees—especially Alolan Exeggutor, since it’s Dragon-type and there’s a notably tall tree in the pacific known as the Dragon’s Blood tree. If Eggsecute was the fully evolved form, or if it was much more clearly and primarily coconuts, it would be on this list
-on that note, Cherubi and Seedot aren’t here because they aren’t fully evolved, if I included every stage of every one this list would be way too long. And neither of them stay food when they evolve—that is, if you even consider an acorn a food to begin with
-TogeKriss repeatedly mentioned Pumpkaboo, but Gourgeist is ultimately not only more than just a jack o’ lantern, a jack o’ lantern itself is already not meant to be eaten. Yes, people eat pumpkins, and often the seeds taken out of a pumpkin when carving it are the same ones that are roasted and eaten, but by the time it’s a jack o’ lantern, they (should be) all gone. It is a decoration, not a food, unless you like rotten pumpkin rinds that have been sitting out in the weather, on a dirty porch, for at least one whole night.
-I also at one point considered putting Eisecue here. Hear me out, it’s a penguin with an ice cube, and ice cubes are often put in drinks not unlike how salt is put on food. Since I already had Garganacl here (which is salt) and 2 drinks, I really thought about putting it in too, but decided against it because ice is so much more broad than salt and freezing it into a 3D square doesn’t always necessarily mean it’ll be in a drink

Big thanks to u/TogeKrissSPB for helping me figure this out!

To clarify, this is only for Pokemon based on some specific food. Not all food-based Pokemon are edible (like Ludicolo), and not all edible Pokemon are food-based (hence why Slowpoke isn’t here despite its tails being frequently mentioned as being tasty). That being said, if you think I missed one, please say so in the comments, there’s a good chance I did. Additionally, if you want an explanation for why any of these are here I’d be happy to answer.

Specifically asked for permission to send this here, so credit to u/mindsunwound for showing me this.