I think recent update made BL4 a fantastic game! That being said - BL4 clearly shows what I don't want to see in BL5
Just to state the obvious.
This post is clearly subjective and just my own personal thoughts.
BL4 is great game and recent update that finally added proper, fun endgame loop AND waaaaay better alt leveling option than goddamn vile bounties, made the game a proper addition to Borderlands family of games.
But as we're one big expansion away from the end of roadmap - I finally got thinking about what I personally don't like in BL4.
Thankfully the list is not long as IMO the game is super fun and easly my 3rd favorite BL/WL game.
Anyway to the point. Things I don't want to see in BL5:
1 - Open world.
It was a cool experiment, the idea of freedom is here but - just like soooo many open world games - it's just not that much fun tbh.
I MUCH more prefer "wide linear" design of BL3 where each planet had massive map to explore but the overall game design was linear. IMO BL3 hit the sweetspot combining exploration with better pacing.
Not to mention, open world kinda kills the pacing AND biome diversity.
2 - Different licensed parts on guns.
Just like with open world. I get the idea behind it. On paper - awesome. The idea was to create more diverse playstyles. In reality tho - You're actually griding even more to get THE roll and combination that's sooooo much more powerfull then the others. So smth that was supposed to open up gameplay, actually made it worse by having to grind more for specific combinations.
3 - Almost entire endgame relies on timers.
Like I said. Recent endgame updates were great! That being said - Everything is about timers now.
Game is rewarding you from using THE most OP, meta build that skips entire sections of gameplay and punishes you from experimenting with builds or using off-meta weapons.
I would totally get if clearing endgame content under 12min. gave you achivement or cosmetic as a reward but being FORCED to farm in specitif timeframe goes against a lot of looter shooter principles.
4 - And finally: Class balance.
We're almost a year into BL4 lifecycle and game still has entire trees that are soooo underpowered that almost noone uses them.
And adding to the point before - about endgame forcing you to use meta builds - there's literally no reason to use certain trees/skills. It's crazy how much BL4 relies on meta builds. IMO - way more than any previous BL games.
Aaaand that's about it.
I love the game but it's not my favorite. I think it's ok tho - There were a lot of new ideas and risks taken with this one and I'm glad for it. I also hope Gearbox is NOT gonna go towards "live service" route and BL 5 will still be a solo/coop game.
Sorry for long post.