Tell me all about living in these Northwest Bronx vs Northeast Bronx Neighborhoods!
My husband and I are planning to leave our beloved North Brooklyn. Planning to have a kid soon, so school zone / district are top priority (yes, we know school zones sometimes change), but we also just don't expect NYC housing to get cheaper and we plan to retire here within the five boroughs. Locking in housing costs where we see great deals in areas we like now is the goal. And sadly, North Brooklyn (and most of Brooklyn but not all) is at the higher end of our budget to buy. We might pivot in the future, but seems wise to act soon. For context, we're an interracial couple (I'm black, my husband is white), we are both used to living in predominantly white areas, we're also both used to living in less urban areas growing up so the shift isn't really a shock compared to living in North Brooklyn, and we're leftist but we understand that these areas aren't going to be the most leftist regions ever. We're considering a few options and one is moving to the Bronx, with these neighborhoods as a focus at the moment:
Northwest Bronx : Riverdale/Spuyten Duyvil, Fieldston
Northeast : Pelham Bay and Pelham Gardens
Looking at neighborhood stats, school data, and articles is one thing, but I want to hear from you all! Please compare and contrast these based on your knowledge or just answer for the areas you're familiar with.
- Especially for people who have lived in both areas, which feels more family-friendly and why?
- How do Riverdale/Spuyten Duyvil and Pelham Bay/Pelham Gardens compare in terms of community feel and neighborliness? Social scene?
- What are the biggest inconveniences of each area that don’t show up in articles or data?
- How do the commutes to Manhattan and the rest of NYC feel in practice, not just on paper?
- If you were raising children, which area would you choose and what would be your deciding factors (schools, parks, activities, etc.)?
- Anything that surprised you after moving to either neighborhood - good or bad?
- How do the neighborhoods surrounding these areas feel in practice? Do you tend to stay within the immediate neighborhood, or do you regularly spend time in nearby areas as well?
- What’s the broader surrounding area like beyond the neighborhood boundaries?
- How connected do these neighborhoods feel to the rest of the Bronx, and how does that affect your day-to-day experience?