r/Frugal_Ind

Started tracking my expenses for the first time. This was a mistake.

Started tracking my expenses for the first time. This was a mistake.

Downloaded an expense tracker with main character energy ready to finally "understand my finances".

Cut to me now, staring at 50 transactions in the first week of July alone, most of them from Swiggy and Zomato, going through the five stages of grief in real time. Denial (this can't be right), anger (why did I order food), depression ( again why do I order in so much) acceptance (unavailable).

Ignorance really was bliss. I used to just vibe through the month. Now I open the app and my own spending judges me before I've even had coffee.

10/10 experience. Please send help.

u/HighkeyTiramis-u — 9 hours ago

What can i do better in this?

Im 21, in hand salary is 35k and i stay with my parents , is there anything i can do better? The financial services shown in may is also investments.
All of these expenses are just mine and i contribute none to my family as of now , i have already made an emergency fund and now i split the invested money into different mfs.

u/Coldbutter666 — 8 hours ago
▲ 11 r/Frugal_Ind+4 crossposts

Which Voltage Stabilizer Should I Buy for My Bosch 14 place Dishwasher?

I recently purchased a 14-place setting Bosch dishwasher. Could someone please suggest a good voltage stabilizer that's suitable for it?

If you're using one with your Bosch dishwasher, I'd really appreciate your recommendations and experience.

u/Vegetable-Key2926 — 21 hours ago

How much is too much for a coconut?

I don't mind spending more on healthy, clean food as much as possible. I used to love drinking coconut water and would often have two coconuts a day when they cost under ₹60 each.

Now the same coconut costs ₹80-90 apiece. Spending ₹180 a day on coconut water just doesn't make sense to me anymore, so I've cut back on buying it.

Do farmers actually benefit from these higher prices, or do most of the profits go to distributors and middlemen?

Also, what are some good natural and healthy alternatives to coconut water that you would recommend?

u/NoMedicine3572 — 1 day ago

how do i get my 600 back

So i bought a trimmer on like 28th june and just yesterday i saw its price like went down by 600 fricking rupees and i felt so bad, like i want to return it by lying but i almost feel like i am acting like a cheapskate, which i am, should i?

reddit.com
u/anarchy_0804- — 24 hours ago

PVR & Cinepolis gift card discount on CRED

Time to put those useless cred coins to use.

There's on going discount on gift cards on CRED. 21% off on PVR 28% off on Cinépolis They're valid for a year and can be used on multiple movie and F&B transactions. So plan your year ahead.

Pro tip: SBI Cashback card earns you 5% CB on top of this.

IMPORTANT: Read the redemption instructions for PVR carefully before you buy. DO NOT directly add it to their wallet.

PS: I'm not affiliated to any of the businesses involved in this. Just wanted to share that their caramel popcorn can be slightly affordable ;)

u/ymopuri — 1 day ago
▲ 279 r/Frugal_Ind+1 crossposts

Why Is Amazon Forcing Open Box Inspection With an Additional Fee?

Yesterday, I ordered one product, and I was charged ₹99 Open Box Delivery fee. In that case, I could understand it because the product was expensive.

However, now I am being forced to pay the ₹39 fee for this order as well, even though I don't need the service. If Open Box Delivery is meant to prevent fraud, then it should simply be a standard part of the delivery process not a paid service charged to the customer.

As a customer, I am already the one at risk if something goes wrong with the order, yet I am expected to pay extra for a process that primarily benefits fraud prevention. That doesn't seem fair.

I am also an Amazon Prime subscriber, so it's even more disappointing to see an additional mandatory charge for something that should be included as part of a secure delivery experience.

u/Plus_Instruction_401 — 2 days ago

20 year old umbrella being used at my home

My mother bought this umbrella in 2005 for 40 rs. Still working, being used and may have been repaired 2 to 3 times. We do have other umbrella but mom uses this only.

I had AC(Samsung) which was used for 18 years, fridge (whirlpool)for 17 years and washing machine for 17(videocon) years... well that story for some other time.

u/CoolSpeaker462 — 3 days ago

Turning 50 this year, need to share my experience and sought feedback

I will turn 50 this year (Phew !). I am married and have a 11 year old son. Been working at a consultant in an IT company. Total net worth has crossed 2 CRs which included Mutual Funds, EPFs, PPFs, NPS, Gold etc. Have a Zero debt. So you can say living life comfortably (Touchwood). Love collecting stamps, old collectibles and watch movies on IMAX, though I am careful to be within budget spending on these stuffs.

When I was in my 20s, I used to thought that turning 50 means turning old. But here i am, hitting half century in next few months, but still hasnt started feeling 'that old'. There is still childlike excitement about upcoming new movies and stamps :)

Only thing that has changed is that I don't crave for most material things now. They dont give that much happiness now. I used be an avid reader but found reading boring now. Same case with gaming. I used to own PS2, PS3 and PS4 but gaming too doesn't excite me anymore. I hardly finish any Netflix series.

Only thing that matters is a good clean home to stay, well being of family and a fit body.

I am not sure if this is part of some 'mid life crisis' but I am happy to be contend with whatever I am.

Is anyone experiencing the same feeling ? Or any thoughts to share?

P.S

This is my first Redditt post. I love reading posts on Frugal_Ind and has learned quite a bit :)

reddit.com
u/Illustrious_Sign7243 — 4 days ago

People think that those who don't 'spend' money are cheapstakes(kanjoos) but the reality could be more layered

My family(Im 27M parents in late fifties) both my father and mother are government employees(state education department) and I'm also one(different department live in a different city for job)

Own house in hometown where my parents live no EMI no outstanding loan no dependents by god's grace.My income is roughly 67k a month and I spend 20-25k a month and save or invest the rest(meaning saving 65 percent of my income).My parents combined income post tax is 2 lakh a month and they spend around 30k-35k a month(4k electricity bill 3k on milk every month) rest on groceries fruits house repairs miscellaneous etc average out annual expenses come out to be 4-4.5 lakh. They save close to 80 percent of the salary and use only government debt instruments like FD RD PPF etc. Both are covered under Old Pension Scheme and also state government medical insurance for which they pay annually 10 thousand each

However the point of the post-our lifestyle is extremely basic even when we don't have a financial problem because we are satisfied with what we have. My father drives a 11 year old wagonr and would replace it with another wagonr costing around 6-7 lakhs because he uses car only for local commute or rarely outstation. The two wheeler in my house is splendor which again is 10 years old

I too here purchased a new splendor and commute through it. I remember saying to my friend when I was preparing for jobs that my lifestyle with job would be exactly similar to my lifestyle without one and it still stands true. My most expensive purchase(apart from splendor plus which costed 93k on road) is a pair of shoe which I recently bought which cost me 2k. I don't know if it sounds weird but there's a lot of mental peace that comes with not spending money on anything other than essentials and a bit more. Basic lifestyle is gold combined with no debt

So yes some people don't spend money not because they are cheap but because they don't see the point of it.

reddit.com
u/khurjabulandt — 3 days ago
▲ 35 r/Frugal_Ind+4 crossposts

Would you spend ₹16k repairing this 6-year-old O General AC or just replace it?

I need some advice from people who have experience with O General ACs or AC repairs.

I have an O General 1.5 Ton Split AC (Model: ASGG18CGTA) that I purchased in 2019. Honestly, it has been a troublesome AC almost from day one.

Issues I've faced

  • Cooling has always felt weak. Even when it was new, it never cooled as well as my LG 1.5T AC that I bought in 2020. The difference has always been noticeable.
  • Gas has been refilled 3 times in 6 years. This makes me suspect there's a slow refrigerant leak somewhere.
  • Last year, the PCB failed. I got it repaired through Urban Company.
  • The repaired PCB failed again within 3 months, so UC repaired it again under warranty.
  • Now, the PCB has failed yet again.

Current dilemma

A brand-new PCB replacement will cost around ₹15,000–16,000.

Considering:

  • Weak cooling since the beginning
  • Multiple refrigerant refills
  • Repeated PCB failures
  • The AC is now about 6 years old

I'm wondering whether it makes sense to spend another ₹15-16k on it.

Would you:

  1. Replace the PCB and continue using it. Also get it checked for leaks and gas refill (+2-3K) = Total 18K to fix everything.
  2. Sell the AC as-is and buy a new LG AC instead?

Has anyone had similar reliability issues with O General, or am I just unlucky with this unit?

I'd really appreciate hearing what you'd do in my situation.

u/damnitrahul — 4 days ago
▲ 160 r/Frugal_Ind+1 crossposts

What's the cheapest practical way to purify water at home without installing a full RO? Renter friendly solutions only.

Okay so I've done a lot of research on this and want to share what I found because I couldn't find a single clear post compiling all the options.

My situation: Rented flat in Mumbai, landlord said no permanent installations, water TDS is around 180-220 (not terrible but not great), spending ₹400/month on 20L cans which feels wasteful and honestly I don't fully trust those either.

Options I found and what I actually think:

**Gravity based purifiers (Tata Swachh, HUL PureIt basic)**Pros: No electricity, no installation, ₹1,200-2,000 upfrontCons: Slow, needs manual refilling, takes up counter space, filter replacements add up

Kent table top ROPros: Actually works wellCons: ₹8,000-12,000, still needs drilling for drain pipe, wastes 3L for every 1L purified — not practical for renters or people who care about water wastage

Tap mount purifiersPros: ₹500-1,500, zero installation (literally just screws on), no electricityCons: Most are just sediment filters pretending to be purifiers — you have to be careful about which brand you trust.

Found one from ZeroB (Ion Exchange) called Suraksha Tap 2.0 at ₹2,000 that seems legit because Ion Exchange has been doing water treatment since the 1960s, not a random brand. Been using it 2 months, water tastes noticeably cleaner.

UV wands / portable UV purifiersPros: Actually kills bacteria and virusesCons: ₹2,500-4,000, doesn't remove dissolved solids or chemicals, battery dependent

Filtered water bottlesPros: Portable, doubles as your daily bottleCons: Filter capacity is limited, not ideal as your only home solution

My conclusion: For renters the tap mount + a filtered bottle combo is the most practical under ₹2,500 total. Tap mount handles home cooking and drinking, filtered bottle handles outside.

Would love to hear what others are doing — especially people in Mumbai/Bangalore/Delhi where water quality varies a lot by area.

u/notyourpizza69 — 5 days ago

Do you judge frugality based on earning?

I know frugality is very subjective and based on how much one earn it can become a debate if someones miser or frugle .. So wanted to understand if people judge based on how much one earns

I'll start, I'll not pay for uber if i can have access to metro and it take 20 minutes extra.

I'll take it if weather conditions are bad and have lot of luggage.

I dont believe in getting instamart or snabbit for hpuse cleaning.. I like to clean house myself.. Dont see value in getting someone to deep clean ..

Will u judgement change if one earn monthly 50K, 1L and 2L and still believes in the above

reddit.com
u/Deadzombii — 4 days ago

If you were an employer, would you be frugal spending on your employees ?

So recently I got an increment at my job where i was allowed to negotiate my final CTC. I am already in the 30% tax bracket. And it is wayy better than what most other folks make with my level of experience and skills.

I told them a number and they agreed without negotiation. I was hoping they would negotiate so I was more prepared to take a lower number. I was a bit sad that maybe I should have asked for a higher number but it was fine.

Now the interesting part is, I got more than what we decided upon. They told me I am important and stuff so they just rounded it up to a higher value. Maybe i give them a better ROI but i highly doubt that as they are making negligible profits and it is just running on investor's money.

Though the new increment from their end was not much but that got me thinking I would have never given that if I was the employer. I would have negotiated hard in the first place. I would have tried to save as much as possible for the company. Though it is investor's money anyway but it is money only. If i was running a startup, i would have done a lot of cost cutting on expenses even if i had ton of money lying around.

But i guess, you would have to avoid being frugal when running a company to be successful. Though my company is not at all successful by any means and i don't see much hope of it doing good later. But it has its perks.

What would you do if you were an employer ? Would you still be frugal on your employees and expenses ?

reddit.com
u/NotPlayingCharacter — 4 days ago

Insights from tracking every single rupee for one month.

Overview: I (25M) recently landed a Central Govt job at a Level 10 Pay Scale. I was raised in a typical middle-class environment, and somehow the grind brought me here. My in-hand pay is around ₹1.01L per month. The extra ₹8,000 you see in my total income (on the top left) comes from lenders (mostly friends) paying me back.

This is the first time in my life I am getting a six-figure salary, so the mindset of being anxious over every rupee spent was natural. Even after getting the job, I would panic every time I bought a movie ticket or went to McDonald's. I am slowly learning to not let money control me and instead use it reasonably.

I track this using Money Manager by RealByte (highly recommend, no need for premium, only one ad a day). Here is the breakdown:

  • Home Expenses: Rent is ₹14,000, and electricity is around ₹1,000 per month. The rest goes to groceries. I recently started the gym, so my order includes mostly meat/fish followed by dairy and other household items. My daily breakfast is a standard oatmeal (oats, milk, seeds, nuts, fruit, and whey protein from a jar I bought months ago).
  • The Other Home Expenses: This goes back to my hometown. It includes ₹12k-₹15k for my father's business needs, plus Wi-Fi, phone recharges, and basic shopping for them. I have an elder sibling who contributes equitably from his end.
  • Food: I thought I was spending too much here, and I wasn't entirely wrong. I make my own breakfast. Lunch is at a fulfilling dhaba outside the office (₹150-₹200/meal, capping at ~₹4,400 for 22 days). Dinner is a tiffin service at ₹100/day (~₹2,500 for 25 days). For the remaining 5-6 nights, I Swiggy or eat out at someplace nice, and I cook my own weekend lunches (included in Home Expenses).
  • Lending: Never thought this would be 1/8th of my salary! I lend small sums to friends still in the struggling phase of their careers. They are highly responsible and pay me back as soon as they can.
  • Transport: Autos and Rapido cost me around ₹90-₹100 per day (both to and fro). Occasional cab rides take ~₹200 per ride in cases of emergencies. The rest goes toward 3A/2A train tickets to visit my parents and relatives fortnightly who don't live too far.
  • Health & Fitness: ₹1,500 for the gym membership, with the remainder going toward medicines and non-medical health expenditures. As this month I spent around 1400 towards some blood tests.
  • Fashion: ₹150 Haircut, random home accessories/utilities, and recently getting into skincare.
  • Leisure (₹100.00): Bought a damn tempered glass screen protector for my phone.

I invest around 25,000 per month in Mutual Funds and Index Funds. I am still learning the ropes of investment.

Any inputs and advice are welcome. Mostly looking for advice on how to reduce guilt when spending on oneself!

u/LifeNotStonks — 5 days ago

Front load washing machine detergent

Hi Guys, I just want to know that what do you guys use for your front load washing machine since I noticed that front load matic liquid detergent is economical as compared to powder.

Could you guys guide, what's good in long to avoid wear and tear in machine

reddit.com
u/Hefty-Doubt-2495 — 3 days ago

Low budget meals ideas please

Hii i am a student staying outside of home and not in a hostel. I love cooking but it's so expensive to cook tasty dishes please give me your favourite cheap dishes that don't taste horrible

Edit - Love y'all so much thank you for the awesome suggestions

reddit.com
u/Maleficent_Sea2100 — 5 days ago
▲ 37 r/Frugal_Ind+6 crossposts

JotWell - Private expense tracker - Free

App Name: JotWell

What it does:
JotWell is a local-first Android expense tracker for people who still prefer manual logging over bank-linked apps. I built it after using Monito for years and wanting the same quick flow: open, enter amount, pick category, done.

Key Features:

  • Local ledger with no account or bank link
  • CSV/XLS import and JSON backup
  • Recurring entries, widgets, monthly stats, and optional on-device SMS suggestions

Goal: Launch / feedback

Giveaway: None

Link: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=design.kishore.jotwell

u/trollmania1 — 5 days ago

Should I move closer to college or keep commuting? Looking for a financial and lifestyle perspective.

I'm a college student in India trying to decide whether renting near my college makes financial sense.

Current situation:

College is 13 km from my home (26 km round trip).

My bike gives around 40 km/L.

Fuel costs me about ₹1,500/month.

I've been commuting for the last 2 years, and honestly it has led to burnout.

The commute also means dealing with rain, traffic, headaches, and accident risk.

This semester is different:

My schedule is almost 8 AM to 6 PM every day.

I leave home around 7 AM and reach back around 7:30 PM.

Because of this, I've had to stop going to the gym and have very little time or energy left.

A few friends have rented a 2 BHK for ₹33,000/month. If I join, there will be 7 people, so my share of the rent will be around ₹4,700/month. Food would cost roughly ₹200/day (about ₹6,000/month), plus some utility expenses.

Family context:

Household income: around ₹1.4 lakh/month.

Monthly expenses: ₹80,000–₹1,00,000.

My family can comfortably afford it, but I still want to make a sensible financial decision.

Would you spend the extra money to save the commute, reduce burnout, and have time for the gym and studies again? Or would you continue commuting and save the money?

I'd appreciate perspectives from people who've faced a similar decision.

reddit.com
u/CautiousNotice2179 — 3 days ago