r/MacroFactor

Should I keep cutting or is it time to stop?

28M, 180cm. I’ve been cutting since April 20 with macrofactor, with 1–2 week maintenance breaks between 3 cut phases.

Started at 96kg (down from 106kg prior to that purely from being in a depressive part of my life) and now I’m at 76.8kg (scale) and 78 trend weight. I lift 5–6x/week and do cardio every other day. I’ve been bulking/lifting ever since i started around 4-5 years ago, so I have a decent amount of muscle. I’m now pretty vascular, can see a 4-pack (ps: thank you MF), etc.

The main thing making me want to keep cutting is the loose skin around my lower stomach. I honestly think I’d be happy with my physique if it wasn’t for that.

The confusing part in MF, my expenditure has been climbing abit (currently its at 2200), and at 1600–1700 calories it sometimes looks like I’m in a ~1200 deficit, which seems crazy.

Would you guys keep cutting to ~75–76kg and then maintain, or go straight to maintenance/recomp? And how much would you trust the rising expenditure estimate?

I’m mainly trying to figure out when to stop cutting without just chasing a flatter stomach forever.

u/Moist-Leave-8333 — 9 days ago

Where to Go From Here? Maintain, Bulk, Recomp? Something Else?

Hey, everyone. I recently hit a health milestone and would appreciate your advice on next steps.

Here are some details:

  • My body fat dropped from ~32% to ~24% during a cut from January to August using MF.
  • I'm down ~100 lbs overall, with most of the weight lost in the last ~3 years (before pic is sometime in 2020 and after pic is recent).
  • I'm currently around 190 lbs at 5'10" and in my 30s, eating at maintenance since September.
  • I train 4x a week on a UL split (Persist Pump Condition) and don't take creatine.

Now that my body fat is at a more “acceptable” level, I’m unsure how to proceed. I have loose skin (belly, thighs, glutes, arms) and want to build as much muscle to help with this (while considering skin removal surgery as a possible option in the future).

Should I maintain, try to recomp (using Jeff's book?), or consider a bulk? Should I start taking creatine regardless of which approach I pursue? I experienced a lot of diet fatigue at the end of my cut so I do think I need a break from that and worry that I'll just continue to look more and more deflated. Are there other options that I should consider?

Also, should I switch my training program to something like Persist Pump Lift, Jeff's Pure Bodybuilding, or the Bodybuilding Transformation Program, or MFWO to focus more on muscle gain?

Thanks for your input!

u/crustydeer — 9 days ago

What’s the secret formula for skinny fat lol

I’ve been going hard now for 12 weeks and iam down to 16% (could be wrong it’s in body at gym) lifting 4 days a week and working on a weight loss goal.

Kinda not stoked on what I’ve accomplished so far! I look like crap lol. Just an absolute wimp lol!

Just a victim of the internet thinking I should @cut” then “bulk” when I got no shake at all!

I should probably switch to a surplus huh?

58 yo m started at 160 now at 138 . Iam definitely getting stronger but Ian a long ways from jacked lol!

Still don’t have lower abs (crying emoji face)

Program has me at 1890 calories a day and I can barely eat that lol! Sad…

At least I have my macro factor apps to remind me d be iam benching 85 lbs….wah wah wah 🤣

reddit.com
u/pinchecharlie — 8 days ago

How to proceed?

Been using MF since June 8 and during the check in, it asked me to drop down to 1750 cals. I feel like this is a bit too low for me imo. Should I follow it or continue eating at 1801? Goal weight is 183lbs

u/Starfinger10 — 9 days ago

Continue cutting or move to bulk then cut

Hey everybody. I had a question I was hoping to get some thoughts on. I’ve been cutting since July and down about ~10#’s.( I started the cut for our cruise in late August then took a week off before getting back to it. Rough easy image is I’m at 19% BF. We have another cruise in about 6 months and wanted to know everyone’s thoughts on bulking for about 3 months then cutting for 3. Or should I just stick with my current cut phase and start my bulk afterwards. I appreciate the help.

Edit: To add to this post, my current calorie targets are 1570cal/158p/52f/116c at 212lbs and about 19# BF which seems low. Would it be a good idea to switch to maintenance and track for a week and see if it goes up? This should give me more calories to see if it goes up or down. Thanks again.

reddit.com
u/Blkr4vn — 9 days ago

[31M] I'm a little confused about what to do next

Hi everyone, I’m 31 years old, 166 cm tall, and currently weigh about 62 kg. I started working out in June 2025; I had a very high body fat percentage and, of course, began an actual cutting phase in November 2025, when I weighed 68 kg. From that point on—as you can see from the graph—I’ve alternated between various phases of maintenance, mini-cuts, and lean bulking, and in the meantime, I’ve also had two BIA tests; the most recent one showed 18% body fat. I think summer threw me off track a bit with going out and eating larger meals than usual, but I didn’t completely derail: as you can see from the chart, my goal in June 2026 was to enter a lean bulk phase with the aim of going from roughly 60 kg to 62 kg—but very gradually; I wanted to do this from June through October.

August, however, was terrible—I quickly hit 62 kg and had to take corrective action by first switching to maintenance mode for almost a month, and now I’m trying to do a mini-cut to get back down to 60 kg and lose that little bit of fat I’ve accumulated.

I’m confused, though, about the path I should take. Compared to a year ago, I’m much more toned—my progress at the gym has been fantastic—but my belly won’t go away, and I think my body fat percentage is still around 18%, according to my last BIA test.

It's clear that to get rid of my belly for good, I'd still need to lose more weight, but I'm worried about losing too much: isn't aiming for 57–58 kg a bit too risky for my lean body mass? What do you recommend I do? Thank you so much.

u/Keryfia — 9 days ago

No way in hell this label is accurate right?

Was psyched to get this cheesesteak beef (Philly Gourmet brand) cause its cheap and allegedly lean as hell. But looking at it there’s no way this meat is 2g of fat per 112g right? That would be 98% lean. Other similar products seem to list like 5x that much fat

u/Berserk_City — 8 days ago

Lost Lean Muscle Mass During Cut

I just completed a six-month cut. It took me longer than it should have because I was not on a very massive deficit, and I wasn't as committed to my cut as I should have been. That said, as I was not on a very hard deficit, I thought I would finish my cut without losing muscle mass. That does not seem to have been the case. I estimate that I lost at least 2 to 3 pounds of lean mass. I'm currently on maintenance, but would like to try and build back the lost mass. I have come here that perhaps the collective knowledge of the sub can help me.

Further information: 52 years old, male, 5'11", 175 lbs. 13% BF. Using both MF and MFWO. Eat mostly whole foods, with only suppliments/performance enhancers of protein powder and creatine.

How long should I stay on maintenance?

I tried bulking last year, and gained about 8 lbs. After the cut to get lean again it was a net negative experience. When I go back to a calorie surplus, how can I make sure I am not disappointed again?

reddit.com
u/GreaterPathMagi — 8 days ago

How do i get back to my normal weight

So i have been taking creatine for past 2 months while I feel stronger and my muscles are fuller I went from 261 to 269...

I am just wondering how i can get back to my normal weight without losing strength or muscle mass.

I have been in calorie deficit for past 2 weeks I also workout and do cardio 6 days a week but my weight doesn't seem to go down or up.

reddit.com
u/Serious-Version-8210 — 10 days ago

upping carb intake

hi!! i have been getting into running and am training for a 5k. i feel like i dont have a lot of energy for my weekly runs because im in a calorie deficit and eating low-ish carbs. is there a way to adjust MF to increase my carb intake to account for the running?

reddit.com
u/RipNorth2107 — 8 days ago

Smart Progression Question

Hello, i uploaded the bodybuilding transformation excel into the app and everything has been going fine. I am on week 5 of the first section, and as you can see by the image, Smart Progression has my first set up to 23 reps on the lateral raise. It has been increasing week by week.

Is this normal? Is there a place in the app where I can see the cutoff where the weight should increase and reps decrease? My gym equipment settings all look okay, just curious about this.

u/r0ck0n1765 — 9 days ago