r/NetflixDocumentaries

▲ 114 r/NetflixDocumentaries+1 crossposts

Unabomber - Representation has gone too far once again

I just watched Netflix's Unabomber. I have seen many documentaries and biopics on this series of events. This left a bad taste in my mouth because of Netflix's decision to switch the gender of the protagonist, the real forensic linguist named James R. Fitzgerald.

I don't have a problem with creative liberties in a biopic. Obviously, you can't fit an entire investigation or someone's life into a two-hour movie. But there's a big difference between condensing events and changing who actually did something.

In the Unabomber case, the real forensic linguist was James R. Fitzgerald, a man who played an important role in the investigation. Netflix instead created a fictional female FBI agent and gave her much of the investigative work associated with Fitzgerald. That wasn't necessary to tell the story, and viewers who don't know the history can easily come away believing that fictional character actually existed and did those things.

My concern isn't that the character is a woman. It's that when movies and series presented as being based on true events repeatedly alter the identities and accomplishments of real people, they can eventually distort the public's understanding of history.

There's nothing wrong with representation, but I don't think representation should come at the expense of historical accuracy—especially when the real people and their contributions are interesting enough to tell the story honestly in the first place.

reddit.com
u/Str8Logic — 7 days ago

Trials of Gabriel Fernandez

Holy ^#^^€€!!!! This was the most infuriating and sad documentary I have ever seen. I’m not a vindictive person but if I saw these two losers or any of the CFS workers, I’d be ok with less that favorable thoughts! How did you get past the feelings you felt from this doc?

reddit.com
u/Shot_Plantain310 — 8 days ago

Caroline Muirhead objectively is a bad person

Yes, I am talking about the "should I marry a murderer?" Documentary. She did the documentary because she wanted to highlight her experience with the police. I agree that the police did a horrible job dealing with her as a witness. We saw a much different, cleaned up and sober version than the police saw. They saw someone who looked like someone at the tail end of a drug/alcohol bender taking her sweet time to report a murder. She then proceeded to play both sides and try to have it both ways. My jaw dropped to the floor every time she went back with him. You know it was just to get high and drunk. I don't think she deserves jail time but she should not be allowed to practice medicine anymore. I started off by feeling bad for her but by the end of it I only felt sorry for the victim and his family.

reddit.com
u/Longjumping-Sail6386 — 9 days ago

The Keepers - Cathy Cesnik

I finished the series yesterday and I am heartbroken beyond repair.
Excellent documentary definitely my top 5 with closely followed by ICARUS. 3 identical strangers and Dear Zachary.

Law enforcement and every person involved essentially a man is part of the problem and beyond fixable.

-As a good citizen her sister gave the letter to the police and that breaks my heart she will never be able to read it. She should have sued them for this.
-No fingerprint testing done in 1992, 90's was when it become prominent for the law to do it, no DNA test on the cigarette. It was so clear that all of them involved wanted to hush hush the case.
-Only if we believe women and what they are saying for ONCE.
-Father died in his 60's but he GOT AWAY with so much! with the help of everyone involved.
-Who in their right mind will lie about a vagina being cut up and presented in front of them, why would anyone make that up? and of course no one believed him.

The strength and patience of all the women to dig deeper and deeper, warms and aches my heart simultaneously. They almost solved the entire case!

A piece of my heart will always be with Jane doe and I am going to write her a letter this evening.

To all the fellow survivors reading this as a survivor myself. I wanna hug you and never let you go.

reddit.com
u/Euphoric-Mud-7922 — 8 days ago

The Keepers - 2 episodes in.

Ok so i just started watching this yesterday and episode one was very slow with no clue what's happening.
I was getting sleepy and anyway I was thinking to just turn it off.
THEN my pizza arrived and started watching episode 2 and OMG OMG OMG (My jaw is on the floor and I just want to kill that father who keeps inviting girls into his room by announcing on the speaker of which girl to invite, my gut is appalled)
I can't wait to go home and turn on episode 3.
No spoilers please!!

reddit.com
u/Euphoric-Mud-7922 — 9 days ago