r/NetflixDocumentaries

Seriously y'all read the rules. Use the Megathreads

Today alone, before lunch, I have removed twenty-odd posts about The Crash. We are getting so much abusive modmail from people upset that we aren't pulling them fast enough, or that their content is being pulled while others' is seemingly allowed which it isn't it was threads that existed before the Megathread went up.

Please read the rules. Please report people who are breaking the rules and most of all please stop sending hate messages to your all-volunteer mod team because clearly listed rules aren't being followed.

reddit.com
u/FaelingJester — 14 hours ago
▲ 234 r/NetflixDocumentaries+1 crossposts

The Crash documentary - EVP of the victims?

Sorry if this has been posted already! I was watching a recent Law & Crime video on the Mackenzie Shirilla case and commenters pointed out that they can hear a ghostly voice say “she killed us” as the cop buckles her into his patrol car.

I thought this could be the result of editing of the Law & Crime video so I found the raw footage and the voice is indeed still there. You can hear it around the 2:44 mark.

This post is in NO WAY trying to disrespect the victims, Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan. May they rest in peace and my heart truly goes out to their families.

With that being said, what do you think of this recording??

youtu.be
u/meowmir420 — 23 hours ago

Netflix: The crash

So I finished the documentary and I just still have so many unanswered questions in my head about this. I know the easiest answer is that he was trying to break up with her and she got over emotional and angry and did what she did. But it just doesn’t make sense for him to break up with her at 5 AM while she’s behind the wheel, knowing how she is. I just feel like he would’ve picked a better safer time to do this like in the middle of the day at a restaurant or something. If he was already afraid to the point where he wanted his friend to come with him why even get in the car at all and initiate a break up at that.

reddit.com
u/Status-Creme-38 — 22 hours ago

The Crash / Rosie Graham

I hope that Rosie realizes that her influencing career is over by standing by Mackenzie, and judging by her social media accounts having all comments/messages turned off, she does. She couldn't talk to the prosecutor but will talk to Netflix. It's just such a shame as they are all so young and Rosie was so delusional to stand by her murderous friend that she was dragged down too, but hey, that was her own fault.
RIP to the true victims, Dom and Davion. Prayers go out to them and their families. Mackenzie deserves to serve her full prison time and I pray she gets what she deserves.

reddit.com
u/tatekitkylejimmy — 19 hours ago

The Crash - why was she tried as an adult if she was a minor

I do think the trial was really unfair. The evidence do mot rule out reasonable doubt. They made it into a character case which is what changed everyone’s mind and why tf was she tried as an adult when she was underaged? What happened is a tragedy but it’s for sure not a clear cut murder

I posted 10mins ago; posting again as it glitched and wasn’t letting me reply to comments

reddit.com
u/CrabNo5226 — 1 day ago

The Investigation of Lucy Letby: Innocent or Guilty?

I think she's guilty because even if what the defending lawyers/experts say are true, she wrote about the murders and patients' names in her diaries. Something ain't adding up. What say you?

reddit.com
u/alexthagreat98 — 2 days ago

The Duality of Dads: The Crash / Worst Ex Ever

I think both sets of parents in The Crash and Worst Ex Ever's "Deadpool Killer" were put in impossible positions. As a parent, you want to protect your child at all costs, but each family took a very different approach.

Mackenzie's parents (100% pos' btw) seemed focused on protecting her from the consequences of her own actions, while Wade's father was trying to protect Wade from himself and, by extension, from the people he could hurt. I thought it was especially powerful to see Wade's father's compassion extend beyond his own son.

Despite Wade being sick, he was also able to empathize with and show compassion toward the parents of his son's victims. Wade's dad is a hero while Mackenzie's are accomplices

reddit.com
u/PeterGoochSr — 2 days ago

Should I Marry a Murderer

Who has watched this one? Thoughts?
It was interesting to me to watch her go back even after knowing certain things. Like at a certain point I couldn’t even tell if it was denial, attachment, addiction issues, or what…

u/LilLibraLady — 3 days ago

BRO WHAT

In watching the documentary “The Crash” on Netflix about this girl Makenzie who crashed the car killing her boyfriend and friend…she got charged with murder. If anybody is watching it I need to rant lol

The way this girls parents are during the trial talking about how tragic it was for Makenzie and not really noticing the 2 boys that lost their lives. Just makes me soo mad and uncomfortable

reddit.com
u/Informal_Order_8540 — 3 days ago

The Crash…more informative option on the actual crime and trial?

I felt like this covered a lot of different viewpoints, but didn’t cover the actual trial or even the evidence as much as I expected. I know very little about the case. Is there something I can watch that covers that stuff so I can maybe understand more about what they are talking about in The Crash?

reddit.com
u/Individual-Weird5688 — 2 days ago

Delusional one, two, three and four

Everyone in these especially the two at the very end pissed me off this entire documentary. I don’t understand how you could be shown video footage of the car you could show documentation of the accelerator etc. Like two lives are gone, and her parents are giggling and smirking as if there’s nothing wrong and based off of what the school said something like this was bound to happen unfortunately. I feel for the families who lost two people they loved but these people disgusted me the entire documentary

u/OptimalHoliday877 — 3 days ago
▲ 1 r/NetflixDocumentaries+1 crossposts

THE CRASH - Anyone else see this? 🔎🔎🔎

Anyone else think that Mackenzie Shirilla as represented in 'The Crash' embodies a blend of Bhad Bhabie, Kylie Jenner and Charlie Sheen?

*Bhad Bhabie - her revenge and attention seeking behaviour.

*Kylie Jenner - her pursuit of out of reach - status/cultural markers

*Charlie Sheen - her compulsion to inflict consequences for people who go against what she wants. A volatile personality type that views boundaries set by others as a threat to their sovereignty and with that - a willingness to see it to the fullest extent. (Borderline/oppositional defiance?)

I'm trying to understand WHY this happened even after watching the doc. I don't really feel like we got enough insight on the victims or on the perp. I'm left with so many questions!

What questions are you still wondering about The Crash documentary? 🔎🔎🔎

reddit.com
u/READIT_FREAK — 2 days ago

Amy Bradley, Two big questions! 1. Why did they follow the photo and set up a meeting 2. If she left the room wouldn’t it wake up the family? The hallways are insanely bright on a cruise ship..

I need some answers 🫣

reddit.com
u/lucyball11 — 3 days ago

Dont F**k with cats. I am Late to the party

Not sure how I missed this one, I watch mostly documentaries on Netflix, but wow this one blew my mind.

I have questions and I didn’t see a mega thread

  1. Who’s were the second set of hands in one of the videos his mom said was Manny’s?

  2. What was the outcome of his psyche evaluation?? Obviously the kid was very much mentally ill, bipolar and sociopathic.

reddit.com
u/thepurplethorn — 3 days ago

The Crash - I was good friends with one of the victims (AMA)

Glad to see this is finally recognition again. I was good friends with Davion for many years. Ask me anything

reddit.com
u/lilhudak — 3 days ago

Mackenzie Shirilla’s account handler likes a comment implying Davion messed with the gear shift in the crash

I assume the mother liked the comment, because if Mackenzie is maintaining that she doesn’t remember then it would contradict her whole story to affirm that theory. But maybe she did. I’m very glad that she continues to lie & deny intent or guilt. It will make it more likely for her parole to be denied when that hearing comes in 2037. No remorse, no clarity for surviving victims’ families, and sticking to a story that has been discredited in a court of law will help keep her behind bars for much longer, I hope.

It’s incredible that her mother couldn’t even refer to Davion as more than a ‘new friend’ and not a valuable life lost at the hands of her daughter during her statement to the judge, but could like this. She’s comfortable with referring to him as “the football player” and is happy to imply that he caused the crash in some way. It feels violent, beyond cruel. IMO it sounds like blame or partial blame, and it’s super dehumanizing language to use about this young man. Very coded. Like he was some no name person that should be used after his murder to explain why her daughter definitely didn’t do anything. She is obviously hoping to campaign for her daughter to be paroled. This is not a good look. But I recognize they’re all delusional.

Mods - this is not personal info on the subjects of the documentary. It is a public instagram that is up and running with nothing other than what is already accessible there

u/Aggravating-Drink316 — 3 days ago

Mega Thread: The Crash

Moving forward, let’s keep the discussion about this documentary here. New posts will be deleted.

Please read the rules. Disrespectful comments will be held for review and may be removed.

Thank you.

reddit.com
u/cloudmountainio — 5 days ago