
This Doesn’t look Right
My third time making yogurt. First time doing a whole gallon. It smells fine. Is this how it is before it sets or did I do something wrong?
Followed same procedure as last two times.
•Heated to 190F, stirring the whole time.
•Let cool to 115F.
•Tempered half cup of plain full fat Chobani in a separate bowl with some of the cooled milk.
•Wrapped pot with four towels and stuck in oven for twelve hours.
The Chobani and milk were both brand new as I forgot to save some from last time. ETA: Whole Milk.
My other times making yogurt I put it straight into fridge still in pot to thicken for another day, but I don’t strain because we like the non-Greek style. As a result, I don’t know what it looked like between oven and fridge. This time I thought I’d ladle it into jars to get thicker in fridge because I used the big pot for a whole gallon which is why I took a look. And it doesn’t look right.
Thoughts? Suggestions?