r/yogurtmaking

This Doesn’t look Right

This Doesn’t look Right

My third time making yogurt. First time doing a whole gallon. It smells fine. Is this how it is before it sets or did I do something wrong?

Followed same procedure as last two times.
•Heated to 190F, stirring the whole time.
•Let cool to 115F.
•Tempered half cup of plain full fat Chobani in a separate bowl with some of the cooled milk.
•Wrapped pot with four towels and stuck in oven for twelve hours.

The Chobani and milk were both brand new as I forgot to save some from last time. ETA: Whole Milk.

My other times making yogurt I put it straight into fridge still in pot to thicken for another day, but I don’t strain because we like the non-Greek style. As a result, I don’t know what it looked like between oven and fridge. This time I thought I’d ladle it into jars to get thicker in fridge because I used the big pot for a whole gallon which is why I took a look. And it doesn’t look right.

Thoughts? Suggestions?

u/bevwdi — 9 days ago

Rubber band recommendation for sealing top of wide-mouth jar?

It seems like a silly question, but for the life of me, I cannot find the right size rubber bands to close the top of my wide mouth jar.

I place a coffee filter on my jar and would like to then seal up the sides with a rubber band. But every rubber band I've bought has been too large to seal the jar, and too small to be wrapped around twice.

I've googled and gotten a few recommendations, but after buying two packs of incorrectly sized rubber bands, I figured I'd just come here and get your all's advice.

reddit.com
u/Zenovelli — 8 days ago

Tips to thicken without straining?

I’ve made 2 batches of yogurt and they’re just what I was hoping for. I added powdered milk (fat free) to my whole milk before heating for the second batch, but I still strained it to get the thickness I like. I’d rather not strain, it’s just messy and more steps than I want to take on, and I like the flavor of the unstrained better. What are some ways I can thicken it easily next time? Thanks!

Edit: Thank you everyone! To answer a few questions I’ve been using whole/full fat milk. I followed directions on the instant pot, and heated 2 quarts of milk to 180F, which is I think about 82C. (Added 1/2c dry milk before heating) Cooled to 110 and added 2 Tablespoons of yogurt. i think next week I will try adding more dry milk and slightly less starter. If that doesn’t work I’ll try heating longer. Thank you for your help, the people in this sub are so kind and helpfu!

reddit.com
u/Live-Cartographer274 — 9 days ago

Greek Yogurt Gone Wrong

Hi Reddit!

I don’t know if this is the right place to ask.

Please help me identify what I just made.

I was trying to make Greek Yogurt. So I placed the milk and the starter on an insulated ice box with hot pitchers alongside it to maintain a set temperature.

After doing this for 8 hours, this is what happened.

What happened? What did I just make? Can I still eat this? Is this still edible?

Hoping for your replies.

Thank you!

u/LannisterFandroid — 9 days ago

Yogurt turned cream cheese?

Did all that I’m supposed to, the problem is that I used the warm function to incubate it overnight, aka I killed the bacteria because it was up to 140 or so F, but the main question is can I just wrap towels all over the slow cooker pot itself to incubate it? Or would that lose heat too quickly for overnight incubation.

reddit.com
u/Lt_Ziggy — 8 days ago