You guys know how power scaling and time works right…?
I’ve seen some really… interesting arguments or perspectives on this.
A great recurring example I see is involving Vader, which is a good one because we have a lot of material and the passage of time to draw from.
Someone brings up how Vader clears entire capital ships by himself, and someone would respond, “that doesn’t make sense, in attack of the clones he struggled against droids”. He didn’t, but let’s say that’s the case, how would that matter?
The growth and development and training and sheer power that is had in the following decades is a magnitude multiplier.
Power and abilities grow, they don’t stay stagnant.. or even go backwards unless expressly dictated.
So in the revenge of the sith novelization when Anakin has near perfect foresight and clarity in future events, that’s not an ability he is going to lose.
When he struggles against starving slaves as an 11 year old boy in the phantom menace, that doesn’t translate to him still struggling as an above Jedi master level entity in ATOC. And up from there.
It wouldn’t make sense when someone was talking about how strong the emperor is/was and I say, “I don’t think so, when he was in the womb, a Psyker doctor could have killed him”.
That doesn’t make sense. It’s a bad argument. It’s dumb.
Another regular one is when people conflate attack of the clones/clone wars and revenge of the sith anakin. They aren’t even in the same league.
A feat of Anakin struggling in the clone wars show and the somehow translates to him struggle in revenge or the sith doesn’t make sense.
Weaknesses don’t really translate to future. But power and ability does grow.
If he can’t beat someone at point a, he might be able to At point b.
If he can’t beat someone beat someone at point a, he WILL be able to at point b.
At least that past version of themselves. Dooku could at the time of attack of the clones and revenge of the sith have always beaten attack of the clones Anakin. But at no time could have beat revenge of the sith Anakin. Because dookues growth, didn’t match or keep up with anakins.
This gets more complicated with psykers and Jedi, as they seem to continually get stronger but at different rates.
“Base” characters only get stronger with enhancements or training. But then seem to level out.
People become MORE powerful over time. Not less.
Thanks for coming to my ted talk.