Is the sports dsa policy actually good for the singapore sports ecosystem?
On an individual level, its definitely more beneficial than bad because athletes generally get a chance to dsa to a RI or ACS or HCI type of school. But how does this affect the country's sports ecosystem?
From how I see it, if a school allows for too many dsa spots for a sport, it will skew the interschool games competitive integrity. E.g. imagine a school give 11 dsa spots for football. Confirm ezwin most games. Keyword is most. Still got some room to lose but generally will ezwin.
Anecdotally, i heard squash interschool games at some particular division, only has 4 5 schools. And both schools in the finals won every single match, only for the champion to smash the 2nd place 5-0 too. Like, how is that even competitive/fun?
Plus, given how schools also will factor in results to decide whether to continue giving resources to a cca, or even cancel it entirely, the dsa system, if you are not on the benefitting end of it, makes it tougher for schools who cant afford to give dsas to sports. Then it will just keep snowballing where they cant get good placements, school gives less resources, placement worsens, eventually cancel cca.
And the dsa scheme favours the top 'elite' schools for sure.
So it feels like the DSA is a short term thing, but negatively impacts the sport in the long run. Not to mention that dsa favors the wealthier since parents can afford to pump more money into getting the kid to train. Altho this is a separate issue entirely.