
Heaping Plates of Jamaican Classics at This Crown Heights Steam-Table Spot (Gift Article)
I first met Quincy Taylor over on the west side of Crown Heights, where he and his crew (aka his literal family) were firing a slew of jerk chicken on a rogue sidewalk grill set up near Franklin Avenue.
Nothing too unusual about that; you see these smoky, cylindrical beasts all over the place in this neck of Brooklyn. And though I had just eaten way too much food somewhere else, for some reason I stopped and chatted with the amiable Taylor. Which is what led me, a week later, to the opposite end of Crown Heights for a feast at the family's year-old restaurant, Authenticity.
Like those sidewalk grills, steam-table spots such as Authenticity are a common sight around these parts, though quality can vary widely. So if you find a good one—and Authenticity is definitely one of those—you want to remember it. These no-frills joints, spooning out massive plates of saucy meats and rice, offer some of the best dinner deals in town.
Taylor was born and raised in Kingston, Jamaica, and told Hell Gate he learned how to cook from his parents. "We try to keep it authentic here in this neighborhood, with Jamaican flavor," he said. "But the type of food we cook is for everybody."
The "medium"-sized jerk chicken plate, for example, comes with at least a half-bird's worth of smoky poultry, the skin sticky with fire-charred sauce, piled beside a mountain of well-seasoned rice and peas. This is top-tier steam-table stuff, especially after you squirt a bunch of jerk sauce over everything.
And our second platter was even better, starring a mess of funky goat curry that paired shockingly well with a slab of chewy macaroni and cheese. I'm betting that Taylor's dank-looking oxtail would make a fine companion to the latter as well. The beef patty was decent, but I kind of wish I had ordered the cow foot soup instead.
Other points of recommendation here include the chill but friendly vibe, the large cup of tart sorrel, the World Cup playing on TV, and the $6 lunch specials during the week. "I like feeding the people," said Taylor. "I like when they come and enjoy the food and they're happy. I put a smile on their face, and they keep coming back."
Authenticity is located at 228 Albany Avenue, just south of Park Place, and is currently open on Monday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and on Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.