
Song Sung Blue puts cover bands in the spotlight + my 27 favorite Neil Diamond songs
I can’t actually say I’ve seen a ton of Kate Hudson’s TV and movie performances, but after her early-career landmark in 2000’s Almost Famous (and she’s really good in the show Running Point as well), in some ways I think she can do no wrong.
Hudson and co-star Hugh Jackman definitely do no wrong in the 2025 movie Song Sung Blue. The twist is that it’s not a Neil Diamond biopic but rather the story of Mike and Claire Sardina, a couple who met and went on to form the tribute act Lightning & Thunder. Hudson even earned a Best Actress Oscar nomination for her down-home portrayal of Claire ranging through the best of times and the worst of times.
I think if you liked Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga’s actinin A Star is Born, you’ll definitely enjoy this film. The two movies have the same feel albeit with wildly different-sized crowds in the concert scenes. The cover band, called Lightning & Thunder, never broke out of the Milwaukee scene, but had a degree of success and even opened for Pearl Jam because of Eddie Vedder’s love of Diamond.
In fact, Vedder later helped persuade Diamond to allow his music to be used in a 2008 documentary about the couple, also called Song Sung Blue. That documentary inspired writer-director Craig Brewer, whose earlier credits include Hustle & Flow and Dolemite Is My Name, to make this dramatized version.
Song Sung Blue is a story with lots of depth, and the movie has only 132 minutes to tell it. But Hudson and Jackman keep the emotional highs and lows grounded and we root for them the whole way. I actually wish the movie would have not ended so soon or been turned into a TV series. It’s the kind of distinctive story I love to see Hollywood put on screen that shows how a couple of people singing somebody else’s songs can have equally extrardinary lives as the superstars who wrote and popularized the songs.
★★★★½ 4.5/5
And … for my 27 favorite Neil Diamond songs … drumroll please … from 27 at the top to 1 at the bottom
- You Don’t Bring Me Flowers (featuring Barbra Streisand, very dramatic but a little tiresome after about the three-minute mark)
- Longfellow Serenade
- Hello Again
- America
- Soolaimon (this is a sort of silly song I had never seriously considered until watching its role play out on the movie, and now I get it, um, I think)
- Brooklyn Roads
- Red Red Wine
- Cherry, Cherry
- He Ain’t Heavy … He’s My Brother
- Holly Holy (which I had forgotten about until the movie reminded me of its sneaky greatness)
- I’ve Been This Way Before
- I Am … I Said
- Desiree
- Brother Love’s Travelling Salvation Show
- Shilo
- Kentucky Woman
- Heartlight (how can you not love a song inspired by E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial?)
- Love on the Rocks
- Solitary Man
- Cracklin’ Rosie
- September Morn
- Sweet Caroline (this one definitely fell a few notches in recent years with its newfound annoying “jock jams” status)
- Girl, You’ll Be a Woman Soon
- Play Me
- I’m a Believer
- Song Sung Blue
- Forever in Blue Jeans (which I still have the warmest spot in my heart for because I always thought as a kid that it was “Reverend Blue Jeans,” which for some reason I thought was hilarious)