You SHOULD care about the resale value
Imho the advice of saying “watches are not rational purchases so you shouldnt worry about the resale value” is silly and quite frankly ridiculous.
Sure, even if you really really like a watch, if it has shitty resale value, you should take that into consideration. Why? Well so you dont overpay of course. If the resale value is ass, you are likely way overpaying if you buy at MSRP.
You also dont know if your taste may change, wouldnt you want to preserve as much value so that you may take a smaller loss when selling it in favor of another one?
Oh and dont even THINK about the bullshit of “oh if you dont sell it you dont lose anything”. Thats utter bullshit, you lost your money the second you walked out the AD.
Im not saying you shouldnt buy a watch just because the resale value is bad, or avoid wearing one you already own to preserve the value, but just because you are into watches doesnt mean you have to be completely financially irresponsible and cant think shit out logically first. Straight up telling people not to worry about resale value is stupid and irresponsible.