WHO IS EVE REALLY?
Who is up for a healthy debate on who Eve may or may not be?
Is she / was she Alison, forever doomed by old house and Thomas. Maybe she is in the deepest cellars and every time she thinks she’s escaped and coped, wakes right back up again. Maybe as a different person or maybe always as herself but with no memory of the previous life. We also had no knowledge of what Eve looks like.
Is Eve another victim of old house and she really did loose the love her life and it’s just that simple. (Occam’s razer)
Is Eve also doomed to repeat history over and over again. She gave Thomas that scar which the old man in the cabin has. Thomas says “we gave you life” there’s some sort of time loop going on but perhaps that’s just within old house and the surrounding areas. We see that time starts to get funky as it is much throughout the novel. Old house in general as we know it’s special and the source of constant disappearances and strange and unusual activity.
She unknowingly uses portals throughout old house. (Blue cupboard, olive green door) She see’s the girl with black hair outside using the short cut 3 times. This same girl performs the cross pose directly in front of Eve just before Eve violently attacks both page and Thomas.
So could she be a violent host? Host also implies she has been stuck in old house for more than a year…
Religion is brought up time and time again and she has stated that she is a non believer now and lost her religion when she was 17. Is she being punished or is the entity trying to turn her into a believer.
Thomas and co needed a new victim forcing eve to take Alison’s place.
What are your thoughts and theories on Eve?
I’ve placed a few theories as a poll but also happy to discuss any theories along the way.
DONT FORGET WHICH HOUSE YOURE IN 👀