AITAH for encouraging my mother to arrest my twin sister?
(LONG READ) We live in a family of 5, my parents are still married and there are 3 kids. My elder brother (30), and my sister and I (22). Our family is not perfect, and ever since I became a teenager, the common theme of all familial conflict stems from dishonesty.
Not any kind of dishonesty, but thievery of money within our home. When I was younger there has been many moments where my mother would question us kids when sums of money would “disappear “ in the house. It was always known that it was never my dad (he was the breadwinner), and it was never my mother (she was a stay at home mom with an allowance) or me. Simply because I spent most of my time in my room, and never at the scene of the crime.
My elder brother however, has a history of having sticky fingers. Once, he stole 2 500 from the kitchen counter which was meant to pay the maintenance staff but my dad had to find more money to replace what was took. However, my sister was always sneakier with the theft. But her amounts were small. This became a pattern in my family. Money disappears. Nobody fesses up. Then my father replaces the money.
But my dad retired just before covid from his day job, and during covid his business took a steady left turn. Money in the house began to hold heavier weight and every cent counted. But here is where my current dilemma comes in.
Recently (maybe 2 weeks ago) I went to my parents bathroom to borrow a hairbrush from my mother. To find their towel cabinet emptied on the floor with my dad looking at my mother as she frantically went through their safe and towels. I didn't even know we had a safe. Or why my father was still home at such an unusual hour. This is when they begin to tell me that the spare key for the cupboard is missing as well 10 000. A bunch of 200s in a blue envelope.
The whole thing was just gone. I was shocked. Simply because no amount of money of that magnitude has ever disappeared from the house. My dad then told me that the money was going to be used to pay his workers the next day and I begin to downspiral.
My siblings have been acting normal? Who could have taken the 10 000 so audatiously thinking they would not get caught at all? Once my father left to go to the bank once again for the replacement money, my mother then told me that the next day we will be searching everyones room to find the money.
We are a family of colour, and our culture is spiritual. My father went to consult to traditional healer about the matter, to which the traditional dealer disclosed that the “missing” key and money was still in the house but it was stolen by a child. The healer also said they were too fearful to flatly point out who the child is because they fear the child already has a suicidal ideation.
With the new information, my mother and I searched my sisters room first. We went through everything. Under her mattress, in her underwear drawer, between her textbooks. Everything. Until I reached for her coat, which she put in those zip up plastic bags. And inside the pocket I found it. The blue envelope with 200s. I immediately start counting the money as my mother stands next to me speechless.
From the 10 000 that my sister took, only 2 000 remained (I know I'm not using currencies but yeah). I was floored. My sister is like my best friend, if she is not at work she spends most of her time with me watching movies and talking about stupid things. I cannot believe she stole so much money, and just pretended like nothing happened. My mother asked me what to do and that's when I suggested that we get my sister arrested.
Because to my logic someone who can do that to their own family, can do it heartlessly to someone else, and also know or expect to do whatever they want because they know they will get away with it. I'm starting to see my sister completely differently and my mother has told me that getting her arrested will not fixed this.
Just last night mom told me that 700 got taken again from the safe, and that she is thinking of locking her bedroom every night for her piece of mind. I don't know how to handle this, has anyone ever experiences this before? I know I'm not the asshole but maybe I am, I just don't know which direction my family should take, and if my “irrational” input may break my family for good
P.S. We have yet to confront my sister or tell my dad about the money. Our family has hit a four-way stop and we have no idea where to turn