The countless Rogues I've seen in my matches and on yt all punch the air all the time. Damn, I do it myself. Only on Rogue.
I really can't find someone in the roster even remotely close to Emma's style to my liking and because of that don't really consider myself a tank player. I can occasionally play Mag, Rogue or Strange when needed but they all feel nothing like Emma and I can't force myself to like them. Was curious how you feel about Emma's playstyle.
When they add Cyclops (and if after all he is indeed a vanguard) I can see the potential for another Emma-like tank, with his vision casting a similar ray and him being also a master of hand-to-hand combat. At least it could be something.