Best express trains in MTA
Earlier today I made a post about the best express stretches in the MTA, now I’m making one about just the best [all-day] express trains.
2/3 (7 Ave). Yes it’s only one express trunk, but it’s the undisputed king of speed for sure, and it’s extremely efficient and consistent. A few timer signals but otherwise it’s the gold standard for a fast express train in NYC. Absolute rockets, this is where operators unleash their inner demons with no-speed-limit stretches approaching 72 and 50. With being super fast for the vast majority of its route not just this, the 3 is probably the fastest train in the system. Yes the A and 4 are express for longer but not as fast.
E/F (Queens Blvd). Again, absolute rockets. This time delivered IND style with very long express stretches and smooth, straight movement with few curves rather than ultra-high max speed like the IRT, though it’s still very fast. E is also one of the fastest trains in the system for sure, maybe even faster than the A and 3. Only one express trunk but still amazing.
A (CPW/8 Ave/Fulton St). Very fast and smooth, and runs express for a really long way all the way from 168 St to Euclid Ave. Like, that’s crazy. I considered putting the A even higher because it delivers fast express service such a long way (it’s really fast everywhere), but it is definitely quite a bit slower than the 2/3 and E/F and less consistent so I couldn’t put it higher (though coming into 42 is absolutely wild). Still one of the absolute best.
4/5 (Lexington Ave/Eastern Parkway). A few years ago I had this above the A, but now I just can’t. It’s amazing in Manhattan and is very fast skipping a ton of stops, but in Brooklyn even though it’s express it’s very disappointing, often taking the same time as 2/3 trains. Contrast this with the A in BK which just flies. It is more frequent than the A (the 4, not the 5), but still less consistent and slow during rush hour, I just can’t put it higher, definitely not above the E/F or 2/3. Still great though.
B (6 Ave/Brighton). The B is quite fast especially with the new trains. The stretches from 34-W4 on 6th and Newkirk Plaza-Kings Hwy on Brighton are just amazing. It’s consistently fast and smooth. Can’t put it higher because it doesn’t run on weekends and the rest of the route is kinda slow.
D (CPW/6 Ave/4 Ave). Again a 2/3 and 4/5 scenario, where one is “more express” but worse. The D is good on CPW and 6 Ave, but not great in BK, Atlantic-36 can definitely be fast but it’s inconsistent and prone to delays. Even on CPW, the D is very much the little brother to the A. The A just goes consistently much faster while the D crashes the party. Maybe the new R211s will help.
Q (Broadway). The express train with the shortest express portion, only from 57 St-7 Ave to Canal St. It’s not terrible and can get pretty fast, but definitely not nearly as fast as other express trains. It’s been running better as of late though. It used to just crawl past Prince St and 8 St-NYU, even on weekends where there’s no N trains on the express track.
N (Broadway/4 Ave). Slow and disappointing. Broadway it goes significantly slower than the Q, as well as stopping at 49 St and not even running express on weekends. Luckily it’s express in BK from Atlantic Ave to 59 St, but still that’s pretty disappointing and inconsistent, though Atlantic-36 can be fast. 36-59 is just not good.