How much does an authentication sticker impact a grade?

I see a comic at auction that is CGC slabbed with an 8.0, with these comments:

sticker left bottom of back cover
crunch right top of front cover
crease bottom of back cover
spine stress lines spine

It’s a signed issue and there is a Beckett auto authentication sticker on the back.

Is there a standard deduction or grade max for a book with a sticker on it?

I’m wondering how much it can be improved with just removing the sticker

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 6 days ago

Guess the grade — I think I got boned edition

This flaw got an otherwise easy 9.8 got knocked down to…

u/IconoclastJones — 1 month ago

Myth or Truth: An artist can verify a previous signature for a CGC witness to qualify it for SS?

I heard someone say this at a con but was in a hurry and couldn’t follow up.

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 1 month ago

Now that 9.9 and 10 are showing up with more frequency

IMO CGC needs to start requiring grader notes on 9.8s. Need to be a little more transparent.

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 2 months ago

Would this qualify for a free reslabbing?

The inner pocket is tilted so some of pocket is outside the normal border and there is some sort of seam of plastic sticking out on the side.

u/IconoclastJones — 2 months ago

Why do my Nike’s always wear right here?

No other brand does it and it happens with every single Nike pair, worse on the left shoe than the right.

All I can guess is that maybe they’re a little too big? I’m a 14 and there’s no 13.5…

u/IconoclastJones — 2 months ago

Whatnot needs a preorder policy for some items

Given how big comics are on the app now and how many sales are of books that are going to be sent in for grading, Whatnot needs a comic pre-order policy.

The sellers send you a piece of paper to satisfy Whatnot’s shipping guidelines even though the books will take at least 2 months to arrive.

If there’s a problem with the order in 2 months time the buyer has no options via Whatnot for help.

That needs to change.

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

Has anyone every had to make a Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) declaration to import a CGC slabbed book from the UK to US?

UPS is holding up a shipment until a fill out a form declaring which chemicals I am importing and if they are allowed by the TSCA. I have responded to them that they are not raw chemicals, but a finished piece of acrylic, but they have not responded.

So strange, right?

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

Has anyone seen research on the impact of starting bids/auction type or length?

Sellers seem obsessed with $1 starts and either longer normal auctions or shorter sudden death.

Curious if anyone had done work on the impact (as a buyer and potential seller).

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

They’re here!

Five years in to my project I finally have some monarchs in the suburbs just north of NYC.

There’s almost always one by my prairie blazing stars, which have bloomed for the first time after planting last year. Already ordered some more.

I am thrilled and even have some Eastern swallowtail for the first time.

u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago
▲ 152 r/CGCComics

The worst feeling when you open a CGC box…

When you’re FF 50 comes back graded like this, because you didn’t notice it was…missing a page!

u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

“See what I did there?”

As a rule, if you just said this it followed a very bad and very obvious bit of humor that failed miserably.

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

Light smudge on cover of Mann AB21

Anyone familiar enough with grading to know what this would do to the grade or familiar enough with cleaning to know if it’s removable?

It appears to be sharpie based on the signature.

Thanks!

u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

A little pen smudge

Any advice for cleaning up a little pen smudge on a cover? I’m guessing it’s Sharpie so maybe I’m SOL?

u/IconoclastJones — 3 months ago

Do any ratios sell for their ratio after release?

Other than the Artgerm Psylocke from last year, can anyone thing of any ratios that sell for the ratio price?

I’m amazed that people (including myself in moments of weakness) continue to pay upwards of $100 for any 1:100.

Am I completely missing a bunch of examples?

reddit.com
u/IconoclastJones — 4 months ago

Year 4 of mature swamp milkweed and I’ve seen 1 monarch in all that time

At some point i have to assume I’m just not in the migratory path? In the suburbs north of NYC.

I’m building what should be a pollinator paradise, but so far only bees seem to care. Only butterfly I’ve seen seems to be a single cabbage white each year. I know it’s not the same one, but crazy that it’s just one of the same type every year.

u/IconoclastJones — 4 months ago