Am I a bad neighbor for reporting an unpermitted construction that could potentially affect my property?
I’m looking for an outside perspective because I’m feeling conflicted about something that happened with my neighbors.
My neighbors began a major construction project involving excavation and a large retaining wall. Our homes are not especially close together, but the properties are elevated one above another, so changes to grading, drainage, or water flow could potentially affect the property below.
Before the larger construction began, the contractor told me he planned to install a French drain that would direct water toward my property. In my city, directing drainage onto another person's property in that manner is not permitted. I told the contractor that I believed it was illegal and that if he proceeded that way, I would report it to the City.
There is also some history between me and this neighbor that influenced my decision not to confront them directly. They have generally been decent neighbors, and I recognize that they have helped me at times. However, I've had previous problems that weren't resolved even when I tried to address them politely. Balls from their property have repeatedly come into my yard and hit my equipment and cargo trailer. I spoke with the father about it, but the behavior continued. A section of our fence was also damaged, and about three years ago I gave him the broken section so it could be repaired. It still has not been repaired.
Because of those experiences, I didn't believe that approaching them personally about a potentially serious drainage issue would accomplish anything. I am also a single woman, and I have sometimes felt that my concerns were not taken seriously when I tried to address problems directly. So I chose to use the City's established process rather than create a personal confrontation.
After I told the contractor I would report the proposed drainage arrangement, the project became much more extensive. The property was excavated and a large retaining wall was being constructed, apparently without the required permit. I reported my concerns to the City because I believed this work could potentially alter the grading and drainage of the property and therefore affect my property below.
The City halted the project, and it has now been stopped for more than 60 days. I understand that an engineer may need to review the work and determine whether the changes have altered the scope of the land or could create drainage problems for my property.
Today, my neighbor walked past while I was outside talking with a tree-trimming contractor. I said “Good morning” three times. On the third time, she finally responded, “Joyce, I’m not happy with you right now.” I had no idea she knew I was the person who reported the situation. I didn't ask her what she meant, didn't argue, and didn't confirm or deny anything. I simply turned back to the person I was talking to and continued my conversation.
I honestly feel terrible that she is angry with me because, despite the problems I've had, they have been decent neighbors overall. I understand why she would be upset if she believes I caused the project to be stopped. At the same time, I don't apologize for protecting my property. If construction could potentially redirect water onto my property or alter the drainage or stability of the land, I believe I had every right to ask the City to investigate.
What bothers me almost as much is that I don't know how she found out that I was the person who reported it. The contractor knew I had said I would contact the City if he directed drainage toward my property, so it's possible he told them. It's also possible someone else told them, including someone connected with the City. I simply don't know.
I’m considering asking the City how my identity became known because I deliberately used the City's process rather than confronting my neighbors myself. I didn't want to create tension between us, and now there is tension anyway.
So, honestly: Did I do something wrong by reporting the situation instead of confronting my neighbors myself? And how would you handle the situation now that there is tension between you and a neighbor you still have to live near?