Should your personal mechanic be preventative or reactive?
Stupid question of the day - we have been using our family mechanic for over a decade now through 2 generations. He's generally good. He lives 1hr from me now, so unfortunately I cannot see him for everything nor see him often. Most maintenance (oil change, basic fluids, tires, etc) I do at local places closer to me. These local places (think dealership) often do multi-point inspections where they point out a bunch of issues. I then take these issue to my mechanic and his responses are always along the lines of
"so is there a light on?" "do you feel wobbling?" "do you hear clicking?" "do you visually see leaking?"
the answer from me is always "no", so he's always like "when issues start occurring or it's actually time to do maintenance (i.e. 100k, etc), we'll replace it. these other places are correct at pointing out issues, it's not 100% healthy, but I don't think you need to replace ASAP"
He has a very reactive approach = when there are signs something is broken and causing problems, fix it. However, he doesn't take a preventative approach = I see this is eventually going to fail in the next year or so, I'll replace it now