u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0

[SIGN UP] Ultimate Powerscaler Mafia

[SIGN UP] Ultimate Powerscaler Mafia

I present to this sub an event completely different from anything you've seen before. This is not a tournament; rather it is a Mafia game centered around battle of wits. Please read the rules carefully; Mafia can be a complex game, but I tried to make them as concise as possible.

https://preview.redd.it/m51uc62jgw2h1.png?width=736&format=png&auto=webp&s=77200682f975e62b9103d3406a12d62bf977f7ba

What is Mafia?

A party social deduction game also known as "Werewolf" where an informed minority (the Mafia, here the Marines) clashes with an uninformed majority (the Town, here the Pirates). In this iteration there is a third neutral faction, the Warlords, which can be converted to Marines as the game progresses.

What are the basic rules?

Players will receive random roles. Marines know each other's roles and share a group chat that can only be utilized during the night. Pirates, on the other hand, only know their own individual role, and must use social deduction to figure out the roles of other players.

The game progresses by alternating between Day phases and Night phases. Each phase will have its own post. We will progress through one phase every day. We skip Day 1 because it is pointless. So we start with Night 1 at Sunday, then Day 2 at Monday, Night 2 at Tuesday, Day 3 at Wednesday, and so on.

During the Day, everyone can vote to execute one player. Votes must be public (submitted as comments in the Day phase's post) in one single comment. You can edit your vote until the day ends, but posts edited after it ends won't count.

Executions require simple majority to pass. Meaning if there are 10 players alive, you need 6 votes to execute one player. If a simple majority is not achieved, no one will be executed.

During the Night, the Marines will reunite in a group chat and vote to kill one player. They can choose which Marine will carry the kill. Some Marines have kill perks which add an effect to their kill if they are the one carrying it.

Additionally, most abilities in the game can only be utilized during the Night.

Abilities are used by DMing me. Do NOT try to use your abilities publicly.

Abilities are resolved once the Night phase ends. For example, if during Night 1 you choose to investigate someone, you will learn the result of your investigation at Day 2. However, if someone else chose to roleblock you during Night 1, you won't learn anything.

The game ends with Pirate victory when every Marine has been eliminated.

The game ends with Marine victory when the Marines outnumber the remaining players and it is absolutely impossible for the Pirates/Warlords to turn the table with their abilities.

Warlords have special win conditions. By default they don't win with any faction and need to achieve their own goals. These goals can sometimes be antagonistic to one of the factions. They can be converted to the Marines by Sengoku's ability, but this does not make them join the Marine group chat. Be careful when trusting Warlords.

Are there any forbidden actions in this game?

Please pay special attention to this. You can be disqualified if you break two simple rules.

Do NOT, under any circumstance:

  1. Copy paste or screencap my DMs, group chats or anything of the sort, for example in attempts to prove you belong to a certain faction or role. Remember that the spirit of this game is social deduction, you are not supposed to prove through hard evidence of system messages. You may screencap the public main posts of each phase for meme purposes, but that's all.
  2. Privately communicate with other players to share or discuss information pertaining to this game. This might sound tempting, but limited communication is essential for the game's design. There are special abilities that allow you to privately communicate with others, so communication is intentionally designed to be a scarce good. Other than these abilities, all discussion should be contained in the main posts of the game.
  3. Reveal any game information after you have died. For example, if you have an investigative role and die, you cannot share the reports that you received; your only chance to share them is while you are still alive. Also, once dead, do NOT try to influence living players with indirect comments, such as by expressing approval/disapproval for their actions or opinions. When dead, you can keep commenting for meme reasons only, but you can't be a participant that influences the game in any way. Please try to respect this rule as it is essential for the game's spirit.

What happens if I don't take action during a phase?

Nothing happens, but please try to remain active. This game is friendly with busy people; you only need five minutes of your day to make a move. Of course, the game rewards those with more time to discuss with fellow players and analyze the information at hand.

This game could be over within one week, or it could last up to three weeks. It all depends on the flow.

How do I join?

Just ask to join in this post. You can sign-up for 24 hours (until 9am EST).

When does each phase end?

For now the game's phases end at 4PM EST. Meaning actions are only valid when submitted up to that time. I will try to resolve them and post the results before 6PM EST. If I am late, I might postpone the end of phase; this will be specified in the posts.

What are the roles/characters?

Before I reveal the available characters (which will be randomly assigned once the game starts), please keep in mind that some characters have secret abilities. This is by design. However, the existence of secret roles is public information; so you will see in that character's role that they have one or multiple "???" abilities. I still tried to keep the number of secret abilities to a minimum, since predictability is essential for this game's competitive aspect.

Also please note characters can be added or removed depending on the number of people that sign up. The list below is temporary.

The Marines

https://preview.redd.it/sjwf35p4gw2h1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=251f17d382351b00851083624b1581eeefb0fbfd

AKAINU

You are probably not ready. There is nothing anyone can do to stop him other than running away.

DONUT (Passive): Kills any players that attempt to kill you during the night.

KILL PERK - YOU WERE NOT READY: Akainu's kills are unblockable, can't be redirected and can't be roleblocked.

HINA:

The Ori Ori no Mi allows Hina to lock her problems up.

RESTRAIN: Roleblocks the target, blocking their night action. Usable every night.

KILL PERK - JAIL: When killing, Hina will automatically roleblock anyone that visits her (in addition to whoever she targets with RESTRAIN).

AOKIJI:

He isn’t a fan of lethal options; but he is capable of addressing multiple targets at once.

ICE TIME: Roleblocks anyone that visits your target. Usable every night.

KILL PERK - ICE AGE: Instead of killing one single player, Kuzan freezes TWO targets, which roleblocks them for 2 nights and makes them unable to vote during the next day.

SENGOKU:

Despite rarely seeing action in the battlefield, Sengoku can pull the strings behind the scenes and protect his allies when they are under attack.

MARINE SUMMONING: If your target is a Warlord, convert their alignment; they will only win with the marines (in addition to whatever is their default win condition). Usable every night.

BUDDHA’S MIGHT: Protect a target, blocking any attempt to kill them. Usable every night.

BOGARD

A mysterious swordsman with unparalleled loyalty and untapped potential.

INVESTIGATE: Visit a player and learn their role. Usable every night.

SUIT UP (Passive): Bogard shows as a Pirate on investigative reports.

??? (Secret Ability - Ultimate)

The Pirates

https://preview.redd.it/6b2fulzbgw2h1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=afb29cc4d9fddedc4735f4647a77780e8aada0e1

VIVI

Her identity is known by all players from the start, which allows her to guide the Pirates, especially during the first rough days when little information is known.

INCORRUPTIBLE (Passive): Vivi’s identity is known from the start, and her alignment can never, in any circumstance, be converted.

CRIER (Passive): Vivi will cry the identity of whoever tries to kill her during the night, even if the attempt is successful and she dies from the attack.

SHANKS

An opportunistic pirate that likes to make bets on the winning gen.

GROOMING: Intercept this night’s kills, sacrificing your dominant arm to save the life of whoever was going to die, even if it’s multiple people. If this works, those saved by your ability will have their win condition transformed; they will only win if you are alive at the end. This ability can only be used once per game.

RODENT INSTINCT: Flip your alignment and win with the opposing faction. Usable once per night. Everyone will be notified with the message “Shanks has switched sides!” every time you use this ability. Usable multiple times to switch between Pirates and Marines; however, upon the activation of [GROOMING], you can’t use this ability anymore, and your alignment will be locked with the Pirates.

LAW

This powerful doctor brings great utility to the battlefield.

EMERGENCY SURGERY: Protect a target, blocking any attacks against them. Usable every night, but you can’t use this simultaneously with [SHAMBLES].

SHAMBLES: Choose two targets. Abilities targeting player A will instead target player B and vice-versa. Usable every night, but you can’t use this simultaneously with [EMERGENCY SURGERY].

BASIL HAWKINS

Hawkins is a complex utility character that can use several investigative abilities; but he is limited to one single Major Arcana ability per night.

MAJOR ARCANA – WHEEL OF FATE: If you are not roleblocked, in the subsequent day receive a list with four random players, among which at least one is guaranteed to be aligned with the Marines. Usable every night, but limited to one Major Arcana ability per night.

MAJOR ARCANA – THREADS OF FATE: Choose two targets. If the first target dies during the night, learn the precise role of the second target.

MAJOR ARCANA – THE MOON: Choose a target. Learn three possibilities for their role; one will be correct.

PERONA

Not to be underestimated, Perona can bring even the mightiest opponent down to their knees.

NEGATIVE HOLLOW: Roleblock a player, blocking their night action. Usable every night.

FAKE BODY (Passive): Blocks the first kill attempt from each player against you. Upon being blocked, attacker will be notified that the person they attacked is Perona.

KID

This vicious rookie can take anyone down, but he needs a lot of prep time and has clear weaknesses.

DAMNED PUNK: Fire an unblockable attack at a target. After using this attack, you will spend the next two nights recharging. While recharging, any attacks against you are unblockable and do not count as a visit for the attacker. This attack can only be used starting from Night 2.

ROBIN

An investigative character that is rewarded for keeping valuable information to herself.

ANALYSIS: Choose a target and receive a report stating whether they are a MARINE or a PIRATE. Warlords by default show as PIRATES unless converted to the Marines. Usable every night.

EAVESDROP (Passive): This takes effect only after you confirm the alignment of at least one marine with [ANALYSIS]. Every day, and so long as the marine you confirmed is still alive, receive a report with the conversation of the Marines’s group chat over the night. The messages will be anonymized (you won’t know the usernames behind each message). The marines will be aware that someone is listening.

ENEL

Perfect awareness of the game's state at any given time, and capable of influencing both Day and Night phases with his smite.

GLOBAL MANTRA (Passive): Every day, receive a report with the amount of players aligned with each faction. Warlords by default show as Pirates unless converted to the Marines.

SMITE: Choose a target. During the day, it will be publicly announced that a huge lightning strike is approaching your target. This player can’t be executed, since no one else wants to be electrified. During the subsequent night, this player will be roleblocked. Usable once every two nights.

KAIDO

In a 1v1, and so long as his opponent is not aware of his presence, always bet on Kaido.

SNEAK ATTACK: Choose a target. If no one else visited them, kill your target. Usable every 2 nights, starting from Night 2.

WANO’S GUARDIAN (Passive): When not sneak attacking, the Marines can’t attack you.

SCRATCHMAN APOO

Apoo's ability evolves as the game progresses. For clarity's sake he can't use abilities from previous stages; only the stage he is currently at.

CRESCENDO – STAGE 1: Target a player and learn who they visited that night. Usable every night. Successfully tracking a visit progresses Crescendo to the next stage.

CRESCENDO – STAGE 2: Choose a word with a length of at least six letters. The first Marine to speak this word will die. Marines will be notified that this ability is being used. Usable every day. Successfully killing a Marine with this will progress Crescendo to the next stage.

CRESCENDO – ULTIMATE: During the day, players can send one anonymous message to you, which will be received at the start of the next night. During the night, choose one message, which will be broadcast to everyone else.

BLACKBEARD

ABILITY ABSORPTION: Choose a target that just died and absorb their abilities. You can only do this twice per game. You must do this immediately after the announcement of your target’s death. The other players will be notified that Blackbeard has absorbed an ability.

Warlords

https://preview.redd.it/vtwp2j7ggw2h1.png?width=3000&format=png&auto=webp&s=8908c8e6080508004b24f15356b3547df9b85ad0

MIHAWK

The World’s Strongest Swordsman. No coping around it.

MEASURE THE DISTANCE: Choose a target. During the next day, it will be announced that a flying slash is heading for your target. If the slash is not blocked during the subsequent night, the target is killed. Usable every 2 nights.

TOP 1 OAT (Passive): Automatically blocks any attack or action used against you during the night. This will not protect you from the marine summoning.

WIN CONDITION: ???

BUGGY

A wildcard with extraordinary potential.

??? (Secret Ability)

??? (Secret Ability)

??? (Secret Ability)

WIN CONDITION: ???

HANCOCK

At the start of the game, the empress of Amazon Lily is assigned a random player as her SOULMATE. She knows her SOULMATE's faction, but not their role. The SOULMATE is aware that they are the object of Hancock's obsession, but they are not aware of which player is Hancock.

MERO MERO BEAM:  Choose a target, roleblocking their night action. If you choose your SOULMATE, instead roleblock whoever visits them. Usable every night.

WIN CONDITION: You win if your SOULMATE wins, regardless of whether you two are alive or not.

DOFLAMINGO

This manipulative and enigmatic warlord will leave everyone confused.

PUPPETSHOW: Choose two targets. The first target’s abilities will be redirected to the second target. This does not count as a visit. Usable every night.

SELF SURGERY (Passive): Resurrect yourself. Can only be used once.

WIN CONDITION: ???

reddit.com
u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 2 hours ago

A certain game is about to start... And I want your input to make it better.

A game is about to start.

Make no mistake; this is no tournament.

This is a battle of wits. And a clash of characters, which will be randomly assigned to each player. The characters decide your abilities and win condition.

I want YOU to voice your opinion on what characters you want to see in the game.

Keep in mind the three main factions that will clash:

THE MARINES (Mafia)

THE PIRATES (Town)

THE SHICHIBUKAI (Neutral)

u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 18 hours ago
▲ 786 r/2007scape

Reminder Jagex is saying they didn’t expect these xp rates but the community told them one year ago during the beta test

Cold take: Perona knowledgechecks your goat. If you don't know how her abilities work prior to meeting her, you get one-shot and there's nothing you can do about it. And barely anyone knows her since she is super low profile.

u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 2 days ago

Explaining both Shanks's and Mihawk's character arc to lazy featscalers that are allergic to narrative

I'm doing this in response to GlitteringBird's post about how Mihawk would be weaker than Shanks btw.

Debunking the idea that Mihawk got his title by beating (or dodging) a fodder pre-yonko Shanks

GlitteringBird said that Mihawk fought Shanks 12 years ago, when he was "getting surprised by a smoke bomb, losing an arm to a sea king", and then "he stopped fighting his rival, considering him weaker since he lost an arm, and thus was considered the winner of their rivalry, earning him his title". This is a common argument that many Mihawk slanderers use.

First flaw with this argument is downplaying Shanks from 12 years ago. His duels with Mihawk were considered legendary by Whitebeard. In fact they are the most noteworthy memories of the old times to him, and this is the man that witnessed the God Valley Incident.

https://preview.redd.it/oh6dp2vkra2h1.png?width=974&format=png&auto=webp&s=3da668bec09feec02da2ec890ce5166630e03a85

So using Chapter 1 Shanks to downplay this narrative is dishonest. It is obvious that Chapter 1 Shanks was retconned. Oda had no idea what he was doing, he didn't even want to have Shanks go through these antifeats, that was his editor's idea. It is painfully obvious that chapter 1 feats were brutally powercrept as the manga went on. This does not mean Shanks from 12 years ago is fodder weaker than Romance Dawn Luffy, you need to use the rest of the manga to interpret this, namely Whitebeard's statement of his duels with Mihawk being legendary.

The narrative points that Shanks's prime was 12 years ago, and that ever since he lost his arm he has never surpassed this power level.

Only a featscaler struggles with this point. After all, a featscaler brain is very primitive and impermeable to logic. They ignore that narratively, from Mihawk's dialogue with Shanks, or Whitebeard's dialogue with Shanks, it is clear that Shanks lost something significant with the arm incident. Shanks himself admits that he made a sacrifice. It is his entire character arc. This sacrifice is pointless if Shanks did not actually lose power from it.

https://preview.redd.it/y4xxf954sa2h1.png?width=1060&format=png&auto=webp&s=2871ddd9d5bd3a55a35daa8d810e955a3bce6368

Most featscalers would now object saying that Shanks "was not even a yonko 12 years ago". This is irrelevant. Yonko is like Pirate King, it's not a power title even though people frequently misinterpret it as such. It's more of a political title.

Case in point: Mihawk is vastly more powerful than at the very least Kaido and Big Mom, yet he was never crowned a yonko because he lacked territory, political influence, a crew and a fleet. Meanwhile Buggy became a yonko as soon as he was perceived to hold a lot of influence over the seas.

So what is effectively Shanks's character arc?

Shanks's story is still unveiling itself, but from what Oda showed so far, it seems like Shanks was setting up the conditions for not only finding the One Piece but also effectively utilizing it. He wanted to avoid Roger's mistake of getting there "too early". To do this, Shanks must live up to the prophecy, which includes using the Straw Hat, grooming Shirahoshi and getting the nika fruit. This is why he stole the nika fruit from CP9.

https://preview.redd.it/emb9qqgota2h1.png?width=446&format=png&auto=webp&s=e793ab5a15c48aa993ec359e7acb4a31eec78ed0

It seems like Shanks thought he was the prophecy child until Luffy ate the nika fruit, which made Shanks realize Luffy must have been the chosen one (since the nika fruit chooses its user). This made Shanks reconsider his entire plan and bet on Luffy instead of on himself. After this incident he becomes a yonko and starts pulling some strings and setting up some win conditions, presumably to support Luffy later on.

What about Mihawk's character arc?

Mihawk is to Shanks what Blackbeard is to Luffy: a parallel, except inverted/twisted.

Shanks cares about the prophecy. Mihawk only cares about power. In fact, pre-Baratie Mihawk knew nothing other than raw, individual power.

Mihawk's mentality is very similar to East Blue Zoro's. To Mihawk, defeat is the worst humiliation someone can suffer, and he would rather die than stay alive after losing. When Zoro begged for death after losing their fight, Mihawk calls him a "strong one". I am not going to paste the pages here because this happens over like 3 pages and it'd spam the post, but here is the dialogue transcription:

Mihawk: Do you wish for me to piece your heart thus? Why do you refuse to step back?

Zoro: Beats me... Not really sure myself... But I get the feeling... That if I were to take even one step back right now, I'd lose something very important to me... A promise or oath... Or whatever it is would be irreversibly broken. And that I'd never be able to return back to where I'm standing right now.

Mihawk: Yes, such is defeat.

https://preview.redd.it/9i0cjwzdxa2h1.png?width=938&format=png&auto=webp&s=651b520160b0afc18d45b9d45c8c5c70911b2f72

Zoro: Haha... Then that's why I can't step back.

Mihawk: Even if it means your death...?

Zoro: I'd much rather die.

https://preview.redd.it/zdk3dmhhxa2h1.png?width=445&format=png&auto=webp&s=b0c2e6e5ebee917def88bee4b1989b008fb28435

Mihawk: (What conviction he possesses! To rather choose death than defeat...) Kid... Tell me your name.

Zoro: Roronoa Zoro.

Mihawk: I shall remember it, for your strength is not oft seen in this world.

https://preview.redd.it/y9p1p7olxa2h1.png?width=297&format=png&auto=webp&s=e76d0c722b938c539b41f6afb2928d9cfc99edd2

This interaction with Baratie Zoro is of unspoken importance, and yet most people ignore it. This is the founding stone of Mihawk's character. This establishes that:

(i) to Mihawk, death is preferable to defeat;

(ii) Mihawk has never lost a fight in his life;

and (iii) for Mihawk, fighting and gaining power is everything in life. He literally would rather die if he can't do this anymore.

Indeed, Mihawk's life revolves around becoming stronger and fighting stronger opponents. He lives for rivalries, whereas for Shanks rivalries and power were just a side mission. You could also interpret that Shanks really cared for power back when he thought he was the prophecy child, but witnessing Luffy eating the nika fruit made him reconsider this and abandon the pursuit for power.

Anyways, Mihawk fought all notable swordsmen in the world until Shanks was the only one left that could match his power. They were equals. Mihawk kept getting stronger to beat Shanks, but Shanks would also keep getting stronger to match him. For a character like Mihawk this type of rivalry is orgasmic, it's the time of his life, after all he lives for power, and during his rivalry with Shanks he lived the absolute pinnacle of power with the only person in the world that could match him, this is way better than sex for someone like Mihawk, you could say Shanks was his soulmate.

And what did Shanks do? He destroyed their rivalry by sacrificing his arm to groom some east smelly crackhead double digit IQ east blue kid.

Remember that, as I established above, when Shanks lost his arm he must have sacrificed some of his power. Which means he became weaker than Mihawk upon doing so.

This is a fate worse than death for Mihawk. He wanted to triumph in their rivalry by becoming stronger and surpassing Shanks. He had no interest in defeating Shanks through Shanks's own concession. Remember how Mihawk's ambition works, he is not necessarily interested in "winning", he is interested in power, and if Shanks trolls their rivalry Mihawk has no chance to grow stronger, on the contrary, he stagnates.

You can see how much Mihawk resents Shanks by the many references and allusions to this in his dialogue. For example, when Zoro disappointed him, he called him a "man that can't finish what he started", because he thought Zoro was doing to him what Shanks had done in the past, aka tainting their rivalry before it could reach its pinnacle:

https://preview.redd.it/7x8tsxrvva2h1.png?width=217&format=png&auto=webp&s=8b34b28ff791f0e9821b33c0daf598e080b3cea7

Again, rivalries are serious business for Mihawk.

Mihawk's vivre card states that he spent these 12 years stagnating. He was barely alive, basically just "waiting until a stronger rival showed up". If he isn't literally waiting in his chair, he is sailing around just to "kill time". He kills some fodder, eats in Baratie, plays with the monkeys, cooks a meal, fucks Perona, goes to sleep, rinse and repeat over and over, that's his depressive day ever since Shanks essentially ruined his life.

Everything changed when he met Luffy and Zoro in Baratie.

Zoro gave him the hopes of a new rivalry that could surpass Shanks, which re-ignited his soul.

Mihawk also immediately realized that Luffy was probably the crackhead kid for whom Shanks sacrificed his arm. He confirmed this with Shanks later on (in the iconic scene where he says Shanks is washed up). Then he went to Marineford to officially test Luffy, and realized that Shanks was right, Luffy is indeed the prophecy child:

https://preview.redd.it/r590gusava2h1.png?width=696&format=png&auto=webp&s=cfae77becdce5754f9275e2f0cc928a2034f9ee5

But notice that Mihawk at first thought Luffy must have been some sort of fighting prodigy, after all power is the only type of merit he knows about. Marineford Luffy disappointed him because Luffy was fodder. But then Mihawk realizes that even though he is weak, he can bring people together, and this is the highest type of power. It is the same interaction he had when he attacked Whitebeard and witnessed his attack being blocked by Jozu: in a pirate crew, the whole is greater than the sum of its individual parts. It allows weaker individuals to transcend greater power of people like Mihawk.

This is all to say that Mihawk finally realized Shanks's motives.

After Marineford, after banging Perona several times, and especially after Zoro talked with him in his castle, Mihawk finally evolved as a person, became chill and learned to forgive Shanks.

https://preview.redd.it/qx3xe88ewa2h1.png?width=769&format=png&auto=webp&s=03ef6e523a1d230fee558f4c79d8cc713c523673

Now he is friends with Crocodile, he accepted joining a crew and he is going for the One Piece, or at the very least tolerating stringing along with other people that are doing this. We don't know what his secondary objectives are by this point, but of course his primary objective remains eventually fighting a Zoro that surpassed Shanks, he never fully got over his obsession with power, he just learned to accept that there are other things in life that are valid too.

But why did Mihawk not beat Jozu? And Vista? And Crocodile? And why did he not single handedly win the Marineford War for the Marines????!!1

I'm not going to waste too much time here because the post is already too long, I'll just point that Mihawk deeply hates the marines, as revealed by Oda in a SBS. We still don't know why, but it is one of the only things we know about Mihawk's past. So of course Mihawk was not keen on killing WBP's strongest commanders (Vista/Jozu) or other prominent combatants like Crocodile, this would swing the Marineford war in the marines's favor and Mihawk wanted to play no part in that.

https://preview.redd.it/oh18wvm6ya2h1.png?width=720&format=png&auto=webp&s=810a3728b45d25edc173cae99ea6344abf5a19a3

Conclusion

Mihawk hard diffs Shanks, and he waits for the day someone stronger than Shanks can take him to ext diff.

Thanks for reading up until here.

reddit.com
u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 3 days ago

Been doubting myself on where to scale Doffy. I know it's a lot, but please answer who wins and what diff, I want some opinions. Doffy vs: 1) Current Sanji; 2) Cracker; 3) Katakuri; 4) Ulti; 5) Vista.

I hate Dressrosa and always skipped it when rewatching/rereading. This time I'm doing it and some things hit different.

Doffy clearly defeated G4 Luffy during their first fight and would have killed him if it wasn't for a lot of plot armor and external intervention.

In their second fight Doffy was severely injured by gamma knives and a bunch of other side fights. To the point he had to do surgery on himself to merely stay alive. People will say Kaido was injured to underplay his defeat against Luffy, why do we pretend Luffy beat a fresh Doffy?

Featwise there seems to be powercreep after Dressrosa, but narrativewise there is no powercreep. This is like saying Doffy is stronger than Oldbeard just because his feats are more flashy, it's featscaler logic.

I'm tempted to say fresh Doffy would beat G4 Luffy 100% of the time, but I want to hear more takes before settling on this

u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 4 days ago

Look at how dishonest Shancucks are. They always slandered Mihawk for his only feat being "cutting ice". Now that cutting ice is suddenly gigantic upscale, they are retconning their slander and saying Mihawk "can't even cut ice". Zero consistency, zero honesty.

Reminder that Mihawk cut an island-sized block of ice from several miles away with a nameless casual swing. That squirrel is fodder for Mihawk.

u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 4 days ago

Mihawk trying to find the perfect angle, force and technique to slash Zoro with Yoru in Baratie WOTHOUT killing him and ruining the manga

If this feat isn't proof that he is the greatest swordsman idk what is. He later on says Yoru can't be held back yet he somehow found a way

u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 5 days ago

After moving my PC that was otherwise perfectly silent when idle became extremely loud (when idle) and I dunno what could be causing this, see video

Keep in mind we are talking about an idle scenario.

My temperatures are all perfectly normal (everything under 40C).

GPU fan inactive.

I thought it was the CPU fan but even zeroing it in the BIOS controls wouldn't make any change to the noise.

I'm running out of ideas here and starting to suspect it could be the PSU fan but I have no idea how to confirm this or what to do in this situation. Tried opening it up to check if nothing moved out of place and it's all normal.

When under load the PC makes the same noise as always. Problem is idle. It makes this weird fan noise that is very high pitched and actually hurts my ears.

u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 5 days ago

I hate when this sub downplays Roger. He was the most powerful pirate and it's not even close.

Lowscalers keep bringing up that he lost against Shiki, but this was a naval battle, and as we all know naval battles are not how pirates fight.

They also bring up that he sneaked around Linlin, but that was PRIME BIG MOM, who transcends the WSM title since she is a woman, you can't blame Roger for not wanting to deal with this.

Being unable to defeat Primebeard is also no reason for downplaying him. Roger had cancer. There's the panel of his doctor stating he is in peak fighting condition, but doctors get stuff wrong all the time, hell we're talking about pirate times back when they didn't even know people microorganisms existed, their medicine was a joke.

Being unable to defeat Garp also does not count because Roger needed Garp alive to take care of Ace (yes he used future sight to know that Garp would accept the task)

Having never defeated anyone in a 1v1 is, too, inconsequential, because as we all know no one was competing with Roger for the One Piece (other than everyone I mentioned above at the very least), so he basically had no opponents y'know?

Finally, circumnavigating is the best feat you can do in this manga. Roger's navigator deserves a raise

reddit.com
u/Reddit_Connoisseur_0 — 8 days ago