u/Upbeat_Dance_9014

btw i draw commissions for precisely 200,000,000 dollars go to me website if interestde

this hypothetical is fairly simple, what if smile and sgt peppers switched places?

in 1967, after a very complicated process of making the album, almost shelving it completely for a multitude of reasons, the beach boys release their long awaited follow up to pet sounds, smile. while not being popular immediately, it would soon be regarded as one of the best records of the 60s, and an early concept album.

however, things did not go so well for the beatles. during the sgt pepper sessions, john falls off the roof, injuring himself. after this they decide to shelve the album, but not before releasing its first single, strawberry fields forever/penny lane

later that year, the beatles released hearty heart, featuring some new tracks, the aforementioned single, and some very pared down tracks from the original sgt peppers.

HEARTY HEART

side 1:

strawberry fields forever

when i’m 64

i will

wild honey pie

only a northern song

side 2:

penny lane

the fool on the hill

lucy in the sky with diamonds

hello goodbye

fixing a hole

baby you’re a rich man

SMiLE:

side 1:

our prayer/gee

heroes and villains

vege-tables

wind chimes

i’m in great shape

the old master painter

cabin essence

side 2:

good vibrations

do you like worms

child is the father of the man

wonderful

the elements

you’re welcome

surfs up

a hypothetical 2016 tally hall album (and their first ever double album), which partially parallels the beatles white album.

spotify link: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3yN9kSi1kdzNja9USxvOOJ

length: 94 minutes

disk 1:

isle unto thyself (hawley) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]

i’m gonna win (hawley-cantor) [from rob cantor - not a trampoline]

miss melody (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]

bring her along (hawley) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]

white ball (hawley) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]

lemons and pears (horiwitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]

garden of eden (cantor)[from rob cantor - not a trampoline]

black people white people (hawley) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]

HEY YOU! (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]

perfect (cantor) [from rob cantor - not a trampoline]

the apologue of hot rod duncan (hawley) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]

fishes (horowitz) [from edu - MONSTERS]

time machine/moon waltz (cantor-hawley-karaca) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii and cojum dip - cojum dip respectively]

disk 2:

daisy fingers (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]

rotary park (hawley-sedghi) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]

old bike (cantor) [from rob cantor - not a trampoline]

“the medley” (hawley-cantor)

- bahamian rap city [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]

- variations on a cloud [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]

- welcome to tally hall (reprise) [unreleased but demoed tally hall song, uses original track from tally hall - marvin’s marvelous mechanical museum as placeholder]

just a friend (cover) [from tally hall - just a friend]

hummingbird (horowitz) [from edu - sketches 3D]

the mind electric (hawley) [from miracle musical - hawaii part ii]

the rainbow connection (cover) [from edu - sketches 3D]

aristole’s denial (hawley-karaca, hidden track) [from joe hawley - joe hawley joe hawley]