AITAH for expecting my boyfriend to follow through on the promises he made after calling me a burden?
I'm 25F and my boyfriend is 27M. We've been together (on and off) for about three years.
Throughout our relationship, we've had the same recurring issues. I caught him lying multiple times, hiding conversations, talking to random women online, and even talking to his ex once. Every time I confronted him, he would tell me I was insecure, an overthinker, or that I needed therapy instead of addressing why I had lost trust.
Last December, after another argument, he broke up with me and told me I was "a burden." I was devastated and begged him not to leave. Our flights were booked for new year the very next day as well on 31st and yet he said he don't want to meet.
At the end of February, he came back. He apologized, said he had realized how wrong he had been, promised he would change, rebuild my trust, and even said he wanted to marry me. I didn't immediately take him back. I spent about two months thinking before giving him another chance.
Since we live in different states, we met again in May. Because trust had been broken, I wanted to see whether his actions would match his words. I asked him to do one simple thing: follow me on social media.
To me, it wasn't about gaining a follower. It was about whether he would make even a small effort to rebuild trust after everything that had happened.
It's now July, and he still refuses. He says he doesn't like showing that side of his life publicly. The part that confuses me is that he's an influencer who posts almost everything else—his purchases, daily life, achievements, and photos with his parents. He also follows and interacts with many other women online.
Whenever I bring this up, he still tells me I'm insecure and overthinking things.
For context, I've always been loyal. During these three years, I never entertained other men, even though I had opportunities to. I genuinely wanted to build a future with him.
Outside of this relationship, I have a full-time job, I'm the eldest daughter in my family, and I handle a lot of responsibilities. I'm not trying to control him or his career. I just wanted honesty, transparency, and consistency from someone who says he wants to marry me.
At this point, I don't know if I'm expecting too much or if I'm ignoring a pattern of broken promises.
AITAH for expecting his actions to match his words after giving him another chance, or am I being unreasonable?