s04e04 of SNW might be one of the worst episodes of TV I've ever seen
I watched it with a few friends and we were trying to parse what was actually going on throughout the entire episode, only to realize it was as dumb as we were being led to believe.
What a fucking mess.
The entire Una part is so insultingly fucking ridiculous I don't know how anyone can defend this trash.
So she kind of looks like this collaborator who we find out is a rebel leader and the first person she stumbles into is THE PERSON WHO KILLED HER who doesn't say shit?
Let's set the rest of the hairbrained plot aside, the resistances terrible plan, the mystery box shit on the Enterprise, the writers having no idea what a Klingon is, Kor, so what the actual fuck is this? These writers are so fucking lazy it's unbelievable because this is the keystone of the entire episode.
Una HAPPENS to land on a planet where a woman HAPPENS to look exactly like her, who HAPPENS to have disappeared just recently enough for Una to replace her, and who HAPPENS to occupy the exact intersection of the Klingon occupation and resistance necessary for Una to become the protagonist of their conflict. And the one guy who knows immediately that Una cannot possibly be this woman HAPPENS to keep that information to himself until the writers are ready for the reveal.
No, just no, A coincidence can start your story.
It becomes increasingly dangerous when coincidences are required to keep the story functioning..
This show is written by nepo babies that have never been told "no" in their entire life. That's the only conclusion I can draw from how terrible these scripts are and how they KEEP GETTING MADE.
Writing this out reminded me of Matt Stone and Trey Parker: "If the words 'and then' belong in between those [story] beats, you're fucked. You've got something pretty boring. What should happen between every beat that you've written down is the word 'therefore' or 'but'"
Instead of a single moment of this episode being "Una gets to the planet and is mistaken for someone else and therefore [goes with the flow] but she encounters the person who killed her"
It's: "Una gets to the planet AND THEN is mistaken AND THEN turns out to be...AND THEN also turns out to be AND THEN finds the body AND THEN the guy admits AND THEN completes the rebel mission AND THEN goes home safe"
Matt and Trey are teaching this to a college class and they introduce the concept as "I'm sure you kids already learned/know this".
Trash, complete irredeemable trash. Good riddance to this show, this entire 10+ years of shows, Kurtzman and his entire gang, and any of this fake-trek. I hope Kurtzman never works in Hollywood again.