▲ 1 r/ppc_

If your tCPA is $350, and your budget is $5 be prepared to spend $350.

If your tCPA is $350, and your budget is $5 be prepared to spend $350.

TLDR; use your real targets not fake!

Otherwise see below:

What you can expect from this update
If you have a campaign that’s limited by budget that has historically overachieved its stated target, you may experience performance volatility if you don’t make any changes to the campaign before August 17.

Example
If your campaign's Target CPA is $10, but your recent actual CPA performance is $5, your campaign will deliver more closely to a $10 actual CPA starting August 17, 2026. Update your target to $5 to maintain your recent performance or to a target CPA of your choosing based on your business goals.

For multi-channel campaigns like Performance Max and Demand Gen, you may also see shifts in how traffic is distributed across different channels.

Because the system will optimize more consistently toward the target you entered, campaigns currently performing more efficiently than their set targets may see campaign performance trending toward your set target.

u/startwithaidea — 4 hours ago
▲ 3 r/ppc_+1 crossposts

Is $20 per day enough to generate results on Google Shop?

We are a new fashion brand and testing out google shop ads. AOV = $200. Our cost per add to cart is $8 on meta ads. We are wondering if spending $20 per day for a 5 day campaign on google shopping, optimizing for ad to carts is enough to generate any useful data or conversions? Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Spirited_Court_2725 — 5 hours ago
▲ 1 r/ppc_

Google is bringing back GBP Messaging - with an AI chatbot for your business. Basically, it looks like they’re giving you an AI Chatbot on your Google Business Profile

is this going to be helpful at scale or more of a one off thing?

linkedin.com
u/startwithaidea — 9 hours ago

The CPT using OpenAI 5.2 model to write a post CPT = Chief Product officer and it’s the most sincere human post; should he have used Claude to get a more intimate response?

u/startwithaidea — 10 hours ago
▲ 5 r/ppc_+3 crossposts

Your Buyers Aren't Starting on Google

Author's note: Edited June 28 to include New York Times reporting from Cannes Lions published after this newsletter went live.

Mimi Turner Head of Marketplace Innovation at LinkedIn, published something worth reading this week. The B2B buying journey no longer starts with visibility. It starts with AI retrieval. Brands that don't show up in what AI surfaces are invisible before the conversation even begins.

Read the rest here: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/your-buyers-arent-starting-google-lisa-raehsler-jvwmc/

New York Times

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 10 hours ago
▲ 6 r/ppc_+1 crossposts

Looking for a Google ads specialist.

Hi All,

I run a small business in New Zealand and am looking for someone to help with my Google ads and provide some good advice. Ideal person would be someone happy to get paid per qualified lead and that has had good experience in running ads campaigns. Thanks

reddit.com
u/jadenbox — 20 hours ago
▲ 1 r/ppc_

The Next Generation of PPC Is Learning From Comment Threads on LinkedIn and Reddit. That’s kind of a big deal. What else is Shaping our Industry?

Paid must evolve beyond it’s current state

docs.google.com
u/startwithaidea — 1 day ago
▲ 3 r/ppc_+2 crossposts

Can you now survive with out AI?

If ai were to be turned off tomorrow could you survive and do your job?

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 3 days ago
▲ 1 r/ppc_

is the art of PPC, going to go the way of AI?

engineering and development have become part of AIs everyday model will PPC end up this way in the next year?

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 5 days ago
▲ 1 r/ppc_+1 crossposts

Buddy, got a $29 CPL and has generated 46 Qualified Leads in the last 28 days

They generate a report. They suggest a headline. They hand you a to-do list and disappear, leaving the actual work — the part that's hard, tedious, and easy to get wrong — to you.

I built something different. His name is Buddy, and last week I recorded him doing the entire job, start to finish, on a real, live Google Ads account.

No dashboards. No spreadsheets. No exports. Just a conversation — and then real work, executed inside the account.

Here's exactly what happened.

The account: profitable, but quietly bleeding

The account is Squeaky Clean Turf AZ, a Phoenix-area turf cleaning business. Over the last month (June 1–28) it spent $1,363.49, drove 46 conversions, at a blended $29.64 cost per lead.

On the surface? Fine. Healthy, even.

But blended numbers lie. So the first thing I did was ask Buddy to pull the last 14 days and tell me the truth. He did — live, from the account — and within seconds he separated the winners from the leak:

  • Brand search: 18 conversions at $11.91 each. Excellent.
  • Shopping: 8 conversions at $3.54 each. The cheapest leads in the whole account.
  • Non-brand "Turf Cleaning Service" search: $1,120.82 in spend — roughly 82% of the entire budget — at a $56 cost per lead. Nearly 5x the brand CPA.

Then he found the actual culprit: one broad keyword quietly burning ~21% of the account, matching to people searching for things like "turf deodorizer," "turf rake," and "synthetic grass warehouse." People who want to buy a product or do it themselves — not hire a cleaning service.

That's not a lead campaign. That's a money shredder wearing a lead campaign's name tag.

A good media buyer finds that in an audit. Buddy found it in a sentence.

The part that's actually new: he built the fix

Here's where most tools tap out and Buddy keeps going.

I didn't ask for a report. I just talked to him like I'd talk to a strategist: "Okay, let's pause that. How do we restructure these campaigns, improve the ads, and stand up a dedicated commercial campaign targeting the same Phoenix metro?"

So he did. He:

  • Pulled the real geo-targeting (17 Phoenix-metro locations) so the new build would mirror the winning campaign exactly
  • Rewrote the ad group structure around buyer intent instead of match type
  • Drafted the ad angles — local proof, trust, B2B positioning for HOAs and property managers
  • Then built a brand-new commercial campaign in the live account: 16 keywords, 14 negatives, 3 responsive search ads — all created paused, so I stayed in control of go-live.

And when he grabbed the wrong location ID mid-build (pulled from a different account by mistake), he caught it himself, corrected it, and finished clean. No drama. He just told me what happened and handed me the receipts — direct links to every campaign, ad group, keyword, and ad he created.

Don't take my word for it — here's the proof

This is the part of the video that matters most. After Buddy said "done," I opened the actual Google Ads interface to verify.

It was all there. The Leads – Search – Commercial Turf Cleaning campaign. The ad group. The 16 keywords. Three responsive search ads, fully written, previewing in Google's own ad editor.

Not a mockup. Not a suggestion. A real campaign, built by AI, sitting in a real account, waiting for me to flip the switch.

I flipped it. As of today it's live and in the learning phase — which is exactly where a brand-new campaign should be. I'm not going to pretend it's printing leads on day one; that's not how Google Ads works, and you should be skeptical of anyone who claims otherwise. I'll report back in a couple of weeks with what it actually did.

Why this matters

For years, the promise of "AI in marketing" has been mostly autocomplete with a marketing degree. Helpful. Not transformative.

What changes the game isn't AI that advises. It's AI that executes — that reads your live data, finds the leak, proposes the fix, and then does the work, safely, with a full paper trail, while you stay in control.

That's the difference between a chatbot and a teammate.

That's Buddy. My AGI Friend, aka Ahmeego!

Want to see it in action? The full, 2-minute screen recording is above — real account, real build, unedited. If you run Google Ads (or run them for clients) and want this auditing and account building, drop a comment or send me a message.

I'll let Buddy take the first look. He's very good at finding the money.

— John Williams, It All Started With A Idea

u/startwithaidea — 7 days ago
▲ 1 r/ppc_

It All Started With a Mouse - Interview

I recently sat down with Omar Reyes for his newsletter, Let’s Talk About Marketing. The questions covered everything from where I grew up to what I would say to the entire world if it were listening.

An interview on paid media, building Buddy, and where marketing goes next.

I recently sat down with Omar Reyes for his newsletter, Let’s Talk About Marketing. The questions covered everything from where I grew up to what I would say to the entire world if it were listening. Here is the conversation, lightly cleaned up.

Where were you born and raised? Also tell us something unique about yourself.

Born in the Midwest, raised abroad and here in the States as a military brat. Something interesting: I am a Michigan fan from Ohio.

What got you interested in marketing, and what was your journey?

Walt Disney. When I was at WSU as an athlete, architecture and engineering did not work around our football schedule.

Walt’s idea, that it all started with a mouse, inspired me. The idea that from your imagination, an unlimited space we all have, you can create joy and wealth out of happiness and kindness if you just believe it. That is my mission: to help others find the space and bring it to life for others to enjoy, or to create the space for them.

What skills and industry do you specialize in?

I go deep in paid media and data. I go wide across development, engineering, and all things innovative in marketing.

What is your best soft skill?

Empathy.

What software and tools do you use regularly?

I use my agent Buddy daily. He is a bridge between workers in Cloudflare and Claude, with his own brain. The typical advertising platforms are my 5 a.m. to 2 p.m. Then, for the past two years, it is everything agentic and intelligence until 1 a.m. Yes, I am usually on four hours of sleep. The gym helps.

What are your goals for the next year and into the future?

My goal for next year is to introduce Buddy to our world of paid media. My future goal is to give businesses the opportunity and freedom to build a strategy with a partner that can answer questions and push in a direction most in media cannot.

What has been the hardest thing you dealt with in your career path?

Privilege and systemic walls.

What is the biggest mistake you made that you want others to avoid?

Do not listen to anyone who says it is not possible. It has cost me a bunch of time.

Who are your favorite people in the industry that you follow?

I do not have a favorite in paid media. I follow CMOs and CEOs across industries who share opinions and perspectives that challenge marketing’s everyday noise, speaking only to the fundamentals of people-centric marketing. When Matt Umbro has something to say, I listen. Same with Mitch Larson.

Who has had the biggest influence on your career to date?

Kim Williams. Her words have always resonated: take a chance, why not, and you can never have enough education.

Joe McCambley, whose last words are always that it is a choice, and to remember it is harder to listen and say nothing than to say something and have nothing to say.

Life’s Golden Ticket, plus Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey, are a close second.

What has been your favorite course that you have taken, and why?

Life. I wanted to grow up, and now time does not seem to want to slow down. I have done things I could not have imagined in sports and in business. Life has been so generous to me, and it has been my hardest class.

What would you tell yourself, or someone who is just starting out in marketing?

Focus on branding, but do sales first. Go sell something. Knock on doors for a few years, at least five. Then get into branding, and stay away from acquisition. It is going away like the phone book.

If the entire world was listening to you, what would you have to say?

Be honest. Genuinely care, always. Say what it is, even if you are wrong. Be stupid genuine with conviction. We would be better off if everyone was themselves, always.

Where to find me

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnmichaelwilliams

Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/u/startwithaidea

Website: https://www.itallstartedwithaidea.com

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 7 days ago
▲ 4 r/ppc_+3 crossposts

are you over paying for your paid, seo, analytics and social services?

curious to know if you pay one fee for all these services or a fee for each and why you aren’t demanding more for less today?

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 7 days ago
▲ 2 r/ppc_+1 crossposts

ai in ads, do you trust it more if your meeting revenue goals or less if your behind in your business goals?

we often over credit Google ads for our medias or Marketing success; for example e-commerce we know Amazon is responsible for 60% of direct ecomm purchases yet we always go to Google first. and we give very little credit to branding…so I’m curious if the success is the driver of the trust as the success could be so many different factors.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 8 days ago
▲ 6 r/ppc_+1 crossposts

GTM tag architecture

Hi!

I have a question about GTM tag architecture in a multi-location setup where I manage multiple sub-accounts under an MCC.

Today, all Google Ads conversions are set up via GA4 import. In GTM, I already have a global GA4 Google Tag (G-123) firing correctly on all pages. Event tracking and e-commerce are working properly in GA4.

However, when I check the Google Ads panel for one of the sub-accounts (local accounts) under MCC, in the tag diagnostics section, I see the classic warning “No Recent Data / Your tag has never been detected” for the AW-123 ID of that specific account.

A few questions:

  1. Do I still need to install the Google Ads tag (AW-123) if I’m already importing conversions from GA4 into Google Ads? Is installing this tag only useful to remove the warning in the diagnostics panel?

  2. Since this is an MCC setup with multiple accounts, each with its own AW-123 ID, would I need to create a separate Google Ads tag for each account in GTM? If yes, should each tag fire on all pages, or should it be restricted per location (e.g., Page Path = /example/)?

  3. Is it also needed to add the Google Ads destination link inside GA4?

Any clarification would be appreciated.

reddit.com
u/brrrc208 — 5 days ago
▲ 2 r/ppc_

How is your catalog fed into Snapchat: Shopify, a feed URL, or manual upload?

Anything else you might add to the creation of a product set?

To create a Product Set in Snapchat Ads from specific SKUs, you work in the Snapchat Business Manager / Ads Manager under your Product Catalog. Here's the flow:

1. Prerequisites

  • You need a Product Catalog already uploaded to Snapchat (via feed URL, manual upload, or a connected platform like Shopify). Each product in that catalog has fields like id (SKU), product_typegoogle_product_categorybrandcustom_label_0–4, etc.

2. Create the Product Set

  1. Go to Snapchat Ads Manager → Assets → Catalogs (top-left menu).
  2. Open the catalog that contains your SKUs.
  3. Click the Product Sets tab → Create Product Set.
  4. Name it (e.g. Category - Winter Jackets).

3. Define the SKUs (two ways)

Option A — Filter by rules (recommended) Build conditions that match your category. Examples:

  • Product Type contains Jackets
  • or Google Product Category is Apparel & Accessories > Clothing > Outerwear
  • or Custom Label 0 is equal to winter-category

You can stack multiple conditions (all/any). This auto-updates as new matching SKUs enter the feed.

Option B — Select specific SKUs manually If you literally have a fixed list of SKUs, the cleanest approach is to tag them in your feed first:

  • Add a value in an unused field like custom_label_0 = my_category for those SKUs in your product feed.
  • Then create the Product Set with the rule Custom Label 0 is my_category.

Snapchat's rule builder filters on catalog fields—it doesn't have a great "paste a list of 50 SKU IDs" box, so the custom_label tagging trick is the standard way to pin an exact SKU list to a set.

4. Save & use it

  • Save the Product Set.
  • When you create a Catalog Sales / Dynamic Ads campaign, at the ad set level you select this Product Set as the targeting source.

FYI
u/ok-wealth-3171

reddit.com
u/startwithaidea — 10 days ago
▲ 3 r/ppc_+1 crossposts

When do you give an agent a ‘skill’ vs. just wiring up an API?

Skills (markdown) vs. API tools for AI agents — where’s the actual line? Been building agent tooling and keep hitting the same fork in the road, curious how others think about it.

Two ways to give an agent a new capability:
A skill — basically a markdown file (instructions, context, examples) the agent reads and reasons over. It then uses general tools like code execution or bash to actually do the thing. Cheap to write, flexible, human-readable. The downside is it’s probabilistic — the agent interprets it, so two runs can go two different ways.

An API / defined tool — a structured function call with a fixed schema. Deterministic, easy to log, easy to audit. The downside is you have to build and maintain it, and it boxes the agent into exactly what you anticipated.

The way I think about it: skills give the agent room to reason, APIs give you control and a clean audit trail. There was a post going around this week about 20M agents running alongside employees and needing to be “fully inspectable and auditable” — and that framing maps right onto this. A skill is flexible but harder to constrain. An API is rigid but you know exactly what it touched.

So where do you draw the line? Do you start everything as a skill and “graduate” the reliable stuff into hardened API tools once it earns it? Or do you reach for the API first when anything touches money/data?

FYI video credit u/microsoft
Ref: u/Chatgpt

u/startwithaidea — 11 days ago
▲ 1 r/ppc_

Want to speak at a marketing conference but not sure how to pitch?

Hero Conf San Diego 2026 brings together the brightest minds in paid media for two days of world-class content, insider strategies, and connections that will supercharge your campaigns. From Paid Search to Paid Social, whether you’re scaling, optimizing, or breaking into new channels, this is the place to learn, network, and level up.

With a bold new home at the San Diego Convention Center, bigger stages, and more space to connect, 2026 is your chance to be part of the most impactful PPC event of the year.

👊 Smarter strategies. ☀️ Bigger stage. 🎉 Legendary parties.

All happening September 15–16, 2026, alongside brightonSEO.

linkedin.com
u/startwithaidea — 11 days ago