A little theory about Shelby in Pantheon SMP
So, her backstory is that she was blindfolded on a cliff with her partner who was possibly going to propose to her. But then she died from a lightning strike/the fall after the cliff broke from the lightning strike (according to the wiki/what i remember from my first and only watch of her episode).
My theory is, what if it wasn’t fully an accident? What if Shelby’s partner didn’t want to marry her so they were planning to kill her by shoving her off the cliff? But, because of the lightning strike/cliff breaking, it killed her before they could.
This could be a cool plot twist since, from what i remember, Shelby seemed to care about her partner. Learning that the person didn’t actually care about her in return could be really interesting. My guess for her wish (if she wins) would be to see her partner again so, if this is true, it would be really sad and she would have to rethink what her wish would be.