Rewatched Frozen II, and I think i figured out one of the things that wouldve made it better.
Rewatched F2 this morning, because despite my....admittedly, a bit over the top disdain for it, i wanted to rewatch it because, well first of all, my niece likes it and I need to get use to the second one being on when I visit as that and the first film (....and K-Pop Demon Hunters) is one of the films she likes to watch all the time, and secondly, I am planning on doing a full thesis/essay exploring why Zootopia 2 worked, but Frozen II (in MY personal opinion, anyways), did not.
And one thing stood out to me, apart from...everything i don't like about it (besides the visuals/animation, a handful of moments in the story, & the songs including singlehandedly the best song in the movie "The Next Right Thing") is that, and idk if this is a hot take....I think there needed to be an actual physical villain present. Because the Spirits clearly aren't supposed to be villains according to the narrative, and if they are at least until the reveal, I don't they entirely work, and im sorry but having the Grandad and what he did is not enough.
Say all you want about Zootopia 2, whether you love it, hate it, or somewhere in between, i think that film had the right idea on having a physical threat in Pawbert and the other Lynxleys, along with all the stuff Ebenezer Lynxley did in the past. I think F2 needed to do something to have more stakes or make the stakes that are there feel earned. Now obviously im not saying repeat the last movies villains Hans and/or the Duke because that just equally stupid, not to mention, lowkey boring and pointless, and having it be another member of the Arendelle family wouldn't entirely work either. But I think it needs to a villain who not only works as a dark foil to Anna & Elsa, but also someone whos motivations parallel what Runeard wanted to do to the Northuldra.
For example, it could be someone also seeking out Atohallan, but instead of wanting to learn and gain wisdom, he or she only wants to corrupt it and gain absolute power, and in a way that makes the Northuldra rely on him or her. You could even have said villain not only get to Atohallan first, but also reveal the truth to Elsa. The only catch being is you would still have to rework the climax a bit, because if you still have the ridiculously executed lunacy of Anna luring the Earth Giants to the Dam, you have to explain how said villain gets from Atohallan to where Anna and Matthias is at the Dam. Or just do something else entirely.
But the point is, I think having a physical threat there, would add urgency and stakes that I feel the film desperately needed, and also write the stakes that were "There" alot better because I didnt feel anything in terms of tension.....also, if villain is female get Kathryn Hahn to voice them please, please, please.