Merrily We Roll Along - the movie version we will be getting in about 20 years - actors’ age
I went on way too long, quite unnecessarily - so
TL;DR:
• why did they decide to do a production that would take 20 years to make, but casted actors 10 years older than the initial ages of the characters - instead of casting people around 18-22 (even 24 ok). Would’ve actually been magnificent to see the actors age along with the characters - while actually being the same age as them, instead of 10 years older at every scene?
Long version of my sayings:
So of course, this is regarding the actors’ age. I’m sorry if this is a topic that has been discussed plenty before - I just have never ran into a post about it here or on other subs.
So the point of Merrily (if you haven’t seen it this may be spoiler-ish, though I’m not talking actual plot) is to see a friendship that takes place over 20 years - but backwards, from how it all ended to how it all began.
Now making a movie production that actually takes place over 20 years sounds like such a brilliant, exciting and amazing idea to me - a new fan of the show. A lot because it cannot be done in theatre at all (and I haven’t seen Boyhood, but I’m glad someone has these kinds of projects as their niche).
BUT the point in Merrily is that the characters start out at ages of late teen- early 20 (somewhere between 18 and 21). And I don’t feel like the plot would work if we were to change the characters’ age to a decade older. For THAT REASON, I don’t understand why the casting and beginning of the filming is done with actors in their early 30s. I’m assuming they are just gonna play characters that are 10 years younger than their actual age while filming - and I also feel like this ruins the spark and misses the point of having a 20 years long filming process. I mean at the last (first) scene, Ben Platt or Paul Mezcal (I don’t know who plays Charley and who does Frank, I feel like Ben Platt is definitely a Charley tho, I’ll get mad again if he’s Frank, anyway - back to my point) is gonna be 50!! Though I’m more bothered with them being 30 instead of 20 - cause that’s where age differences matter more.
Anyway, I’m going off course here: I get that they might’ve wanted to take already famous and established, as well as experienced actors, instead of “risking it” but I feel like if you make a tiny effort, you can find ones already established, who have proven their talents and are around the correct age of the characters for the first scenes (ok I can only think of Andrew Barth Feldman at the moment, but I’m sure there are more!!).
So unless there’s already been a secret filming with the Beanie, Ben and Paul for the past 10 years - I feel like this is a HUGE missed opportunity. (I mean you’re already waiting 20 yearsss, why not make the actors’ age fit!!)