It's funny being a sort of new fan who mostly likes the post AM era
It really is. Essentially every single list or discussion of the band dismisses my favourite era. I'm not a huge punk rock fan, so there old stuff (although I do find things to like about it) just isn't for me.
Yes, the songs are less punchy but I like them for how dreamy and meandering they sound. And that jazz/soul fusion sound just works perfectly with Alex Turner's voice.
It's a great transition into something that was bound to alienate fans and, honestly, how cool is that?