
u/Antique_Quail7912

I love RDR1’s slightly more cartoonish/stylized character design/art style
To my eyes, it just really pops and exudes personality. It immerses you into this crazy world you’re about to experience.
There’s this tinge of dementedness and ugliness that imprints both them and the journey you’ve taken on your mind. I love it.
When I say “cartoonish”, I am by no means trying to be demeaning or insulting towards it. On a purely visual level, it looks fantastic, particularly for its time of development.
What I was trying to say is that I enjoy how styilized and comic-booky it feels. Notice how I said SLIGHTLY MORE cartoonish, not cartoonish on its own. Especially compared to how realist RDR2 looks (which I love in its own way). The limitation of the technology of the time had its role, I’m sure, but the way the characters’ personalities mix with their apperances, the facial proportions and expressions, and the contrast and textures lead me to believe they deliberately took a slight deviation from realism and a slight leaning towards art style.
It actually kinda reminds me of Telltale’s Walking Dead a bit.
It lends RDR1 an aesthetic that both sticks out and is able to hold up after much time has passed.
U.S. Deputy Marshals and clerical staff at the U.S. Land Office in Perry, Oklahoma Territory, October 12, 1893
Confederate massacre of black Union troops after the surrender at Fort Pillow, April 12, 1864
Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper (New York), May 7, 1864
Ferdinand Behr, an innocent bystander, being arrested as a suspect during the immediate chaos following the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and Duchess Sophie in Sarajevo, June 28th 1914
Self-emancipated slaves at a Union “contraband” camp in Cumberland Landing, Virginia, May 14, 1862
On May 14, 1862, a group of formerly enslaved men, women, and children gather outside a building on the Foller Plantation, located at Cumberland Landing on the Pamunkey River in New Kent County. During the Peninsula Campaign of the Civil War, photographer James F. Gibson made a series of images of the Federal troop encampment at the landing. Among those glass-plate negatives is this portrait of so-called contrabands, or enslaved people who had emancipated themselves by fleeing behind Union lines.
Advertisement of clipper ship for bringing Gold Rushers to California, c. 1850
Prospectors ascending the summit of Chilkoot Pass, Alaska during the Klondike Gold Rush, 1898
English chemist William Henry Perkin’s photographic self portrait at age 14, 1852
"I played against your father. You did him proud, and I want to give you my shirt." - Ferenc Puskás to Sandro Mazzola after Inter’s 3-1 victory over Real Madrid in the 1964 European Cup final, where Mazzola scored twice
Sandro’s father was Valentino Mazzola, captain of the legendary Torino side which tragically perished in the 1949 Superga air disaster, when Sandro was six.
George photographed by Paul during their hitchhiking trip in Southwest England and Wales, August 1959
Paolo Maldini, Frank Rijkaard, Mauro Tassotti, Franco Baresi, and Alessandro Costacurta for A.C. Milan in the 1992/93 season
Guy Who Takes Arthur to the Doctor Appreciation Post
Badlands (1973)
One of my favorite images in cinema. The evening sky mixed with Sheen’s nonchalant posing always gave me a warm and melancholic feeling for some reason.