I 26F want to break up, but i amscared he 28M will react badly. Am I overthinking this?
​
I've been seeing this guy for about two months, and I'm genuinely confused about what this relationship even is.
When we first met, I wanted something casual. He was the one who kept pushing for something more serious. But every time I wanted exclusivity or asked where this was going, he'd tell me that I'm not really his type, that I don't check his boxes, and that he still needs to meet other people. Yet whenever I try to distance myself or end things, he insists we shouldn't break up and that we should "see where it goes."
Recently, we went on a trip together. We met a couple who got married after knowing each other for just a week, and we were both amazed. Later that evening, he jokingly asked if I'd marry him. I said yes because I assumed it was a joke too. Later, he admitted it was. But he refuses to believe I knew he was joking.
Earlier that day, he had also told me that he likes me a lot but can't love me because we have too many differences. He is from a conservative north Indian family, and I am an east Indian woman. He says we were brought up differently, have different values, and that I don't fit what he wants in a partner. When I asked why he was still trying to make this relationship work, he said he doesn't want to be rigid and wants to explore whether he can "deal with me."
That sentence has stayed with me.
Another thing happened on the trip that really shook me. It was my first time in a swimming pool, and I don't really know how to swim. While we were playing around, he repeatedly pushed me underwater. I panicked because I genuinely couldn't tell if I was okay. My friend got angry, pulled me away from him, and told him, "Don't manhandle her. You're going to kill her."
He was clearly upset that she intervened. Afterwards, he started criticizing me, saying I'm the product of the five people I hang out with, calling me "badtameez," and saying that's my default personality and I'll never change. He also told me how female friendships are of zero values. We fought after that.
I was extremely frustrated and ended up apologizing to him for "ruining the trip," even though I'm not sure I actually did.
On our way home, I read a piece of news to him that said a man has drowned his 6-month-pregnant wife in a bucket. He said "she must have been like you." I was too stunned to speak.
Since we've come back, things have been distant. We've barely spoken compared to before. I'm also sick now, so maybe that's adding to everything emotionally.
Here's what I know: I want to be loved. I don't want to be with someone who says they like me but can't love me. I don't want to spend months hoping he'll change his mind.
At the same time, I can't seem to leave. I'm very physically attracted to him, and I've become emotionally attached too.
Part of me wants to tell him the truth—that this relationship isn't giving me what I need. Another part of me is scared of how he'll react. He's said things before like his blood boils at the sight of me when he's angry, and because of that, I'm honestly nervous about ending it. Some friends suggested I tell him my ex came back into my life and I have unresolved feelings, just to make the breakup easier. But I don't know if lying is a good idea, and I'm worried that hurting his ego could make things worse.
Am I overthinking all of this? Does his behavior sound like someone who's genuinely conflicted, or someone who's keeping me around because it's convenient? And if you were in my position, how would you end this relationship safely?