u/ice_wandering

Okay. You guys were right. The strawberry milkshake poptarts FROZEN are something else. It really brings out the flavor and makes it taste like a milkshake. I loved it! Makes me wonder what other poptarts are good frozen...

As a strawberry milk lover, I LOVED these poptarts. The center is not a jam but like a strawberry cream. It really tastes like a strawberry milk/milkshake. This has made it's way up to top 5 forsure. I couldn't get enough of the filling and frosting combo, it worked together so well. I toasted it so the filling was warm, gooey, and oozing. Sooo good.

Idk how it's my first time trying these but wow, you guys were right. These are sooo good. It's a pretty thick layer of cinnamon filling that gets warm and gooey after toasting them. The top is a simple vanilla like icing that goes perfect with the cinnamon flavor. Dip it in some milk and it's perfection. It almost tastes like a very slight apple cinnamon taste to me. Not in a bad way. Great poptart! Will definitely be keeping these in the rotation.

Just dropping this here...a classic. Dipped in milk when you're craving chocolate, it's the best! Reminds me of being a kid when costco sold chocolate fudge and strawberry in a big pack. Nostalgia and yummyness all in one 😋

I didn't even know these were a thing until I walked past them and just had to buy them...so here is my review. The poptart crust is different here, its a graham cracker flavor and a bit dryer than a regular poptart crust. The white cream inside has a cream cheese/frosting taste and the jam is strawberry flavored jam. I would say these are pretty good but they weren't mind blowing or anything. They definitely do taste of strawberry cheesecake!