Is it wise to turn Political Criticism into Slander?
There is something deeply disturbing about the way we speak about women in Pakistani politics and showbiz.
Whether it is Bushra Bibi, Maryam Nawaz, Benazir Bhutto, Maryam Aurangzeb, Kashmala Tariq, Mahira khan or any other woman in public life, people often move beyond political criticism and start abusing them, insulting their character, and making accusations about their private lives and alleged *haram* relationships.
You may disagree with a woman’s politics or showbiz. You may believe she should not be involved in politics or in media industry from an Islamic perspective. You may strongly criticise her policies, decisions or political conduct.
But none of that gives us permission to destroy someone’s honour without evidence.
Allah says:
“Those who accuse chaste women and do not produce four witnesses, flog them with eighty lashes and reject their testimony ever after. They are the defiantly disobedient.”
— Qur’an 24:4
And Allah gives an even more serious warning:
“Indeed, those who accuse chaste, unsuspecting, believing women are cursed in this world and the Hereafter, and they will have a great punishment.”
— Qur’an 24:23
Think about that.
We often say these things casually because the person is famous, politically opposed to us, or because we assume, “It doesn’t matter, she will never hear what I said.”
But Allah heard it.
The fact that our words may never reach that woman does not mean they disappear. Every accusation, insult, lie and piece of gossip can become part of our record of deeds.
Before forwarding a video, sharing a WhatsApp message, repeating a rumour or making an accusation about someone’s character, ask yourself:
Do I actually know this to be true?
Can I prove it?
Would I be prepared to answer for these words before Allah?
Political disagreement does not cancel someone’s dignity. And being a woman in politics does not make someone’s honour a free target.
We can criticise politicians without abusing them.
We can oppose their ideology without inventing allegations.
We can condemn their actions without attacking their character.
Our tongues are easy to move, but the consequences of those words may be very heavy in the sight of Allah.
On the Day when every word is accounted for, “I was only joking”, “everyone was saying it”, or “I heard it somewhere” may not be an acceptable excuse.