
Thoughts from my May the 4th rewatch Day 1: The Phantom Menace
Honestly, I feel like I enjoyed TPM a bit more this time around, especially the Tatooine sequence. Writing wise, it suffers in the character development department a bit, especially compared to ANH, but I do believe it's more tightly written than people give it credit for. The main writing problems are Qui-Gon taking Anakin to a combat zone for no reason and that we could've used more context about the legalities of the blockade and the trade federation goals. Also, the Battle of Naboo is kinda medicore because of Jar Jar antics and Anakin blowing up the ship largely by luck.
The dialogue isn't as good as in the OT, but outside of some cringe lines, it's not as bad as people say. Qui-Gon is probably the only one with a personality though, although I'll say AotC and RoTS fix that problem. The acting is very stilted sometimes, but Liam Neeson largely carries. Some delicious hints from Ian McDiarmid's performance as well. Jake Lloyd is underrated imo. Also loved Pernilla August.
Overall, a 7/10 from me. Next up: Attack of The Clones.