u/Due-Smoke8035

If u think that court allows Garba or not,its NO because Asirgarh Fort and its structures are under the custody of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) and performing non-traditional religious rituals or large-scale dance events inside this historic place of worship directly violates national heritage laws.

File complaint on Online Grievance via MP CM Helpline portal:

here is link: https://cmhelpline.mp.gov.in/Default.aspx

(1)Fill out the Form select department Home Department (for law/order) or Culture/Tourism Department. Upload Evidence: Attach the video link or a screenshot of the incident

Submit: Note down your unique Grievance ID to track the resolution status online or by calling 181

(2)Now, File a Central Government Complaint via CPGRAMS (For Heritage Violations )

Visit the Portal ; here's the link: https://pgportal.gov.in/ login, register,Choose the Ministry of Culture (under which the ASI operates). Describe the Issue: State that a cultural dance (Garba) was illegally organized inside the religious courtyard of a centrally protected monument (Jama Masjid, Asirgarh Fort) without ASI permission, violating the AMSAR Act.

Submit and save reg no for future tracking.

(3)Send a Formal Letter to Local & Archaeological Authorities this letter you have to do it offline this one is worst but i would really suggest u guys do it and attach screenshot of people doing graba it .

This is the least we can do.

(Credits to- ryococelus)

​

I ain't considering someone who became a revert coz Obv they weren't born with the blessings like we did. They had to find the ultimate truth we were born with. They didn't had the resources and availability like we had.

Ik- most of us were born into homes with the Qur'an but maybe not religious enough parents ; but does this justify someone's grave sin? Sins as worse as Zina?

We were born with the blessing, yet we never acknowledged it. The ultimate truth was lying with dust scattered over it, yet we chose to bring dirt upon ourselves by ignoring it.

I agree and disagree with the title at same time- but I wouldn't justify someone's grave sin committed after/during the age of adolescence.

Agree- coz nowadays we see cr!mes done by kids and it's lack of parents proper upbringing

Disagree- coz I've seen ppl with religious upbringing getting into haram. And ppl with non religious background finding Islam.

I can share some of the incidents on why I disagree-

(1) I've seen ppl who are highly religious, living close to mosque, made contributions to the mosque... Yet getting into relationships.

(2) Many ppl justify it saying it's due to past trauma- so i thought why not my own example:

Im diagnosed with depression. I had lack of love from my own family members since years,lived away from them..lost the ones who loved me when I was a kid and eventually left me when I needed them the most,got assaulted,abused by some of my own family members...yet when I found a na-mehram who could potentially heal me? My conscience didn't allow it. Even after them making first step such as sharing numbers... I didn't rly feel like moving ahead with it. Alhamdulillah.

(3) I'm gonna get backlashed for this-

Music. We all know that music is haram. Yet we never get rid of it completely. Using music to avoid a greater sin is justified but my point is-

We all know that a certain thing is haram,yet we allow ourselves to freely commit it. We are normalising it.

***We are all selective sinners. We commit the sins we are comfortable with and judge the ones we are uncomfortable with.But does this mean we blame the upbringing?***

**Also,one doesn't have to generalise or judge someone for it- no muslim can really attain or follow every hadith/verse of the Quran after the Prophets and the Caliphs.We all violate some or more of the rules.. yet we must all try our best to become a better muslim.**

I ain't considering someone who became a revert coz Obv they weren't born with the blessings like we did. They had to find the ultimate truth we were born with. They didn't had the resources and availability like we had.

Ik- most of us were born into homes with the Qur'an but maybe not religious enough parents ; but does this justify someone's grave sin? Sins as worse as Zina?

We were born with the blessing, yet we never acknowledged it. The ultimate truth was lying with dust scattered over it, yet we chose to bring dirt upon ourselves by ignoring it.

I agree and disagree with the title at same time- but I wouldn't justify someone's grave sin committed after/during the age of adolescence.

Agree- coz nowadays we see cr!mes done by kids and it's lack of parents proper upbringing

Disagree- coz I've seen ppl with religious upbringing getting into haram. And ppl with non religious background finding Islam.

I can share some of the incidents on why I disagree-

(1) I've seen ppl who are highly religious, living close to mosque, made contributions to the mosque... Yet getting into relationships.

(2) Many ppl justify it saying it's due to past trauma- so i thought why not my own example:

Im diagnosed with depression. I had lack of love from my own family members since years,lived away from them..lost the ones who loved me when I was a kid and eventually left me when I needed them the most,got assaulted,abused by some of my own family members...yet when I found a na-mehram who could potentially heal me? My conscience didn't allow it. Even after them making first step such as sharing numbers... I didn't rly feel like moving ahead with it. Alhamdulillah.

(3) I'm gonna get backlashed for this-

Music. We all know that music is haram. Yet we never get rid of it completely. Using music to avoid a greater sin is justified but my point is-

We all know that a certain thing is haram,yet we allow ourselves to freely commit it. We are normalising it.

We are all selective sinners. We commit the sins we are comfortable with and judge the ones we are uncomfortable with.But does this mean we blame the upbringing?

Also,one doesn't have to generalise or judge someone for it- no muslim can really attain or follow every hadith/verse of the Quran after the Prophets and the Caliphs.We all violate some or more of the rules.. yet we must all try our best to become a better muslim.

I want to visit a cafe with too many pets around- especially cats! Is there any in wgl?

Also- are there any places where cats are usually found? A park?

​

This has been going on in my mind and i would love to hear ur thoughts on it.

I live in an islamophobic country yet our ancestors built mslim universities to make sure Islam prevails. Now these universities also allow a certain percentage of non muslims asw...

Earlier the uni was fine,well known..but idk it's been few yrs since and the uni environment has completely changed. Even though our country is islamophobic,most women were hanbali and would consider niqab as fard. It dropped to hijab.. fine and now? Few Ppl dropped off their hijab asw. Before u say- why are u acting as dawah police- the thing is i never searched for them.. it randomly popped up and I observed ton of things regarding this uni. I couldn't beleive it. Earlier the same uni was praised and treated as best uni for mslims. So ofc curiousity kicked in.. I was keeping this uni as my alternate.

Main issues-

(1) Organisation of music events,similar to west but the singers sit on a floor and don't use sl\*rs...alot Abt love,heartbreak..etc. They call it Qawwali Nights. Both men and women would be in the same hall vibing with clapping or moving hands.

(2) Dancing with hijab (on the stage) became common.

(3) Both mslim men and women freemixing and dancing

I could highlight this within 2 vids that popped on my feed.

I thought to bring this to the mslims sub of my country but I got quite hesitant.

2 things-

(1) Other religious ppl could visit our sub and witness all this

(2) I'm not a perfect muslim either

I'll be honest- I had danced on stage as a kid, and sang once 2 yrs back. Both the times I got praised for it. But idk if it's Allah's blessing... I never felt the attraction to it again.I started h@ting those acts and I don't feel confident in it either now. Qawalli nights was organised at my place too.. idk that day I didn't feel like going. But later i kind of regretted it. But now? Alhamdulillah I feel good coz i didn't do that sin.

Maybe there are sins I don't feel comfortable to do but there are also sins I feel comfortable to do.. and others might find them as uncomfortable. I got to know Abt Qawalli nights being haram recently.. and since then I've avoided it. Allah helped me realise it's haram through a vid.. and then also ppl who made a post on why it's haram. Even they were sinners probably.. but if they hesitated to post coz even they know they arnt perfect,would I ever change? Idk. If the person was bashed saying he is a hypocrite, then how would I ever know it's haram? And why it's haram?

But at the same time- I feel like maybe I'm a hypocrite,so i better just focus on becoming better... And also remember the hadith- saying not to become extremist. I wonder wt extremist means here-

Religion is very easy and whoever overburdens himself in his religion will not be able to continue in that way. So you should not be extremists, but try to be near to perfection and receive the good tidings that you will be rewarded..." (Sahih al-Bukhari 39) \[1\]

Wt do u think one must realistically do?

This has been going on in my mind and i would love to hear ur thoughts on it.

I live in an islamophobic country yet our ancestors built mslim universities to make sure Islam prevails. Now these universities also allow a certain percentage of non muslims asw...

Earlier the uni was fine,well known..but idk it's been few yrs since and the uni environment has completely changed. Even though our country is islamophobic,most women were hanbali and would consider niqab as fard. It dropped to hijab.. fine and now? Few Ppl dropped off their hijab asw. Before u say- why are u acting as dawah police- the thing is i never searched for them.. it randomly popped up and I observed ton of things regarding this uni. I couldn't beleive it. Earlier the same uni was praised and treated as best uni for mslims. So ofc curiousity kicked in.. I was keeping this uni as my alternate.

Main issues-

(1) Organisation of music events,similar to west but the singers sit on a floor and don't use sl*rs...alot Abt love,heartbreak..etc. They call it Qawwali Nights. Both men and women would be in the same hall vibing with clapping or moving hands.

(2) Dancing with hijab (on the stage) became common.

(3) Both mslim men and women freemixing and dancing

I could highlight this within 2 vids that popped on my feed.

I thought to bring this to the mslims sub of my country but I got quite hesitant.

2 things-

(1) Other religious ppl could visit our sub and witness all this

(2) I'm not a perfect muslim either

I'll be honest- I had danced on stage as a kid, and sang once 2 yrs back. Both the times I got praised for it. But idk if it's Allah's blessing... I never felt the attraction to it again.I started h@ting those acts and I don't feel confident in it either now. Qawalli nights was organised at my place too.. idk that day I didn't feel like going. But later i kind of regretted it. But now? Alhamdulillah I feel good coz i didn't do that sin.

Maybe there are sins I don't feel comfortable to do but there are also sins I feel comfortable to do.. and others might find them as uncomfortable. I got to know Abt Qawalli nights being haram recently.. and since then I've avoided it. Allah helped me realise it's haram through a vid.. and then also ppl who made a post on why it's haram. Even they were sinners probably.. but if they hesitated to post coz even they know they arnt perfect,would I ever change? Idk. If the person was bashed saying he is a hypocrite, then how would I ever know it's haram? And why it's haram?

But at the same time- I feel like maybe I'm a hypocrite,so i better just focus on becoming better... And also remember the hadith- saying not to become extremist. I wonder wt extremist means here-

Religion is very easy and whoever overburdens himself in his religion will not be able to continue in that way. So you should not be extremists, but try to be near to perfection and receive the good tidings that you will be rewarded..." (Sahih al-Bukhari 39) [1]

Wt do u think one must realistically do?