co parenting concerns of dishonesty
How do you handle repeated dishonesty about who’s around your child when you have no intention of trying to prove it yourself?
I’m looking for advice from people who have been through custody litigation.
One thing I genuinely struggle to understand is this: if there is nothing inappropriate about a third party being present, why continue denying it?
I’m not talking about trying to catch anyone or prove anything. In fact, I have no intention of driving by the house, conducting surveillance, following anyone, or trying to gather evidence myself. I don’t want to do anything that could make the situation worse or reflect poorly in court.
My difficulty is that what I’m told often doesn’t align with what I later experience or independently observe in the normal course of life. That disconnect makes it hard to know when I can reasonably rely on what I’m being told, especially when it involves the home where my child also lives during the other parent’s parenting time.
Part of what makes this so frustrating is that there are countless ways someone could be present without me ever knowing. They work together, so they could ride home together. Someone else could drop her off. She could be dropped off nearby and walk over. He could pick her up from another location before returning home. There are so many possibilities.
The point is I truly have no idea, and I’m not trying to figure it out. I’m not interested in investigating anyone’s personal life.
What I’m trying to understand is this:
If someone is repeatedly dishonest about a third party being present, how does that ever come to light if you’re not trying to catch them?
Has anyone had the truth come out through discovery, witnesses, admissions, or the legal process rather than personal investigation?
How do courts generally view a pattern of dishonesty if it becomes relevant?
From a psychological standpoint, if someone feels the need to continue denying something, what is usually driving that? Privacy? Avoiding conflict? Fear of legal consequences? Something else?
I’m not trying to control who my co-parent dates. My concern is transparency and trust when it comes to the adults who may be regularly around my child. I’d appreciate hearing from anyone who’s navigated a similar situation and chose to let the legal process—not personal investigation—handle it.
Given he has denied this exact third party involvement since Jan and finally admitted what he previously denied in May. Therefore, my trust was so broken. I have since tried to rebuild until he breaks it again himself.