Feel like I’m being replaced
I’ll try to be short so if you have any questions please ask. I’m 21F and my bf is 25M. We had an issue around a week ago where he went to see this other girl without telling me. We promised we would tell each other any encounter we had with anyone else, but his excuse was that he didn’t have sex with her so he didn’t think he would have to tell me. He said they just went for ice cream. But the way I’m feeling is that if he couldn’t even tell me he went to get ice cream with this girl, how can I trust him to tell me when he does more with someone else? That same day I also found out he had more than one partner. He was talking to someone else without telling me. They didn’t meet up but were planning to. Our agreement was for this open relationship to just be sexual but he’s getting pretty emotionally invested in the first girl I mentioned. We can call her Jay.
So yesterday I went to my bfs place (we live an hour 30 away from each other) and when I got there he sprung it on me that Jay was free that weekend so he wanted to bring her back to his place. I said that was okay with me. He brought her back, I eventually left to go get food for all of us and that’s when they had time to have sex. I came back and I felt really awkward.
This is the part that’s bugging me the most. His brother invited us (just me and my bf) to go watch fireworks for 4th of July with his friends, the brother’s wife, and their baby. My bf invites Jay to this family activity and he introduced her to his brothers friends but not me. While we were at dinner he shared food with Jay and his sister-in-law looked at me confused. I made up some lie and said I was sick and wanted to go back to his place instead of fireworks. We went back to his apartment and I lied again saying there was a family emergency and I had to make the nearly 2hr drive back to my town. When I left, they had slept in the same bed together. He has a pull out bed in his living room so I assumed one of them would sleep there, since I don’t ever sleep with my partners in the bed that I sleep with my bf in.
This was just supposed to be sexual and now he’s bringing her around his family and sleeping in my spot on his bed. When I asked him why he allowed her to sleep in bed with him he said “how am I supposed to know what you want and don’t want” I’ve never EVER slept with my other or had them sleep with me in the bed that we sleep in. I thought it was common sense and respectful not to do that. And when I found out he was seeing her behind my back, that’s when I told him “hey this is nearing emotional cheating for me so please be careful”. He talks to this girl so much, telling her details about his day that I’m not even getting. I talk to my partner to briefly catch up or to set up another time to meet up. I’m never telling him deep stuff.
My post got longer than I thought. But this is my first open relationship like this. Maybe it isn’t for me. I just feel like he’s replacing me and not listening to my boundaries. I’m confused because one of my friends said this is what I get for agreeing to an open relationship, and the other one is on my side saying he’s being too emotional and he thinks he’s getting two gfs out of this. I’m not talking to him right now but I doubt he will miss me since he has his backup gf to keep him company. But please tell me, am I being dramatic right now? Should I continue to try and communicate with him or just call it off?