
+32% to the Odds of Having a Child: What Winning a Housing Lottery Did for Young Brazilian Families
Amid the broader fertility crisis, a new study by four economists, from Brazil, Singapore, the UK, and the US, is worth a closer look. The researchers use a natural experiment in Brazil, where housing credit is allocated through a lottery run by "consórcios" (group lending pools). A regular mortgage requires banks to screen applicants carefully, demand a large down payment, and take collateral, so many young families never qualify. A consórcio is open to almost anyone: members just make fixed monthly payments. The lottery replaces credit scoring, and defaults are absorbed by a shared guarantee fund.
For people aged 20 to 25, winning access to housing raises the probability of having a child by 32% and the average number of children by 33%. For people over 40, there is no such effect, which the authors attribute to the biological limits of fertility at that age.
The timing of the housing win turns out to matter as much as the win itself. Someone who gets housing at 20-24 ends up with roughly twice as many children over their lifetime as someone who gets the same housing ten years later, at 30-34. Every year of waiting produces a lasting drop in potential fertility.
The effect is largest for the poorest families and for those who had previously lived in the worst housing conditions.
The study also finds a gender pattern: in households where women earn a high income, housing access has less influence on the decision to have children, which the authors link to the higher career opportunity cost women face.