
Regarding the complaints about having the Painted Lady in Book 2 instead of 3...
/sigh.
I guess haters will always be there to hate, and they'll never accept anything that isn't a 1:1 representation of the source material; that or they don't understand the idea that live-action is a different way of telling the story, limited in terms of the number of episodes, special effects, and a million other things. By now, I should have gotten used to it and shouldn't be so bothered by it. But at the same time, I see how this bunch of people have come out to complain about a HALF-SECOND shot of the Painted Lady and I'm like... why?
Like, let's be honest: The Painted Lady is a great episode, yes. But that doesn't change the fact that it was one of the biggest filler episodes of Book 3 (NOT because what happens in the episode doesn't matter, per se, but because Book 3 in general has very few episodes that could be considered filler, so this one, in comparison, falls far short of the rest).
Now, I know some might say, "No, it's not filler, because it helps Katara's development and shows that she'll always do her best to help anyone in need". Yeah... I mean, duh, obviously that's true. But it's not like the animated show is short on episodes that show this same kind of empathy from Katara, you know what I mean? Even if you quickly assign specific roles to each member of the Gaang, Katara will always be seen as this kind-hearted voice of reason. She is (literally speaking) a healer! She will always try to seek the well-being of anyone who needs her help. It's not like the audience originally learned all this AFTER watching the TPL episode.
And EVEN if we're really nitpicking, if you think about it, I think it actually makes a lot of sense that the episode is there, considering how much depth the live-action is putting into Katara's trauma regarding her mother. We already saw in Season 1 how the original sequence of Kya's murder unfolded through flashbacks, and we saw how that affected Katara's bending in Season 1. If there's ANYTHING truly (and I mean truly) redeemable from the original TPL episode, it's the fact that Katara's decision to help people from the Fire Nation could be considered the first step towards forgiveness and achieving this empathy that we said characterizes her, especially to pave the way for The Southern Raiders episode in Season 3.
And as I said, it's literally just a half-second shot. Literally all we see on screen is fog, and The Painted Lady's hat and hair. The scene could literally be the ghost of the real Painted Lady, like with the Gaang first hearing the legend or something, as a preview of the actual episode in Season 3, considering how many important events Book 3 has to cover in so few episodes.
So, yeah... anyway, I think this post is a bit of a mess. I just kept going around in circles, but it's exasperating to see the same kind of posts and comments over and over again, from people complaining about something so minor. We all have the right to different tastes, that's fine. And nobody is obligated to like the live-action show, or even watch it. But just because of that, you have to argue (and INSULT) anyone who says they liked X scene from the trailer? That's when criticism turns into pointless whining. Comments like the ones I saw online, along the lines of "It makes no sense being outside of B3, you dumb bih", are what really put me on alert here.
Like, chill dude, there's no need or obligation for you to watch something you're clearly not willing to give a chance, especially if you're going to get so worked up over a two-second shot with no context in a trailer...