What if I have secret disbelief in my heart?
I sometimes have a subconscious feeling of unbelief- I don’t quite know how to describe it? Like when you read something fictional and your brain quietly but deeply reminds you “that’s not real”? Sometimes when learning or thinking about God I get that feeling, and I try to correct myself and dismiss it.
I was thinking this morning about what my basis for belief is and I’m worried it’s too weak- I was raised Christian, live in a deeply Christian family. I started believing in God not because I have something I can definitively point to that convinced me, but because it’s just simply what I’ve always known. When I see atheist arguments, the anchor that keeps me from panicking is the thought that if I die and find there isn’t a God, I’ll have lost nothing, and even if someone could prove 100% God wasn’t real I’d still be a Christian anyways, because I think my life is better for it. I like having a guidebook to follow for how to live my life and I like having a God to be loyal to and to cling to when things are rough. So I don’t need 100% proof of his existence because if I believe and find I was wrong I’ll have lost nothing
But I worry this isn’t a good enough justification for my faith. I think about God all the time and worry all the time about sin(it’s a problem really) and living life the way Jesus wants, but what if my faith isn’t real? What if I’m just going through the motions and I’ve deluded myself into thinking I have real faith? I could point to all the ways my life is devoted to God as evidence, but theoretically I could do all those things and still not believe it in my heart. And I know someone will point out I’m talking a lot about works here and not what Jesus did on the cross- I can choose in my conscious mind to say “that’s real and I believe in that,” but what if my unconscious heart doesn’t believe it? You could choose to tell yourself in your head “my bed is lava” and then live your life treating it as such, but somewhere in your mind you still know it’s not lava and your just acting. What if that’s what I’m doing?
And if I really am deluding myself, how can I be saved? I know the story of the man who said “I believe, so help my unbelief,” but salvation depends on our hearts genuine faith in Jesus. I could imitate all the things someone with real faith does and even tell myself in my head that I have real faith, but if my heart still chooses not to believe then I can’t fix that no matter how hard I try. I’m hesitant to say my heart 100% without a doubt believes in Jesus, and it doesn’t matter if I choose consciously to keep obeying the Bible because if my heart doesn’t follow it’s all for nothing. Basically, if I can act like a Christian apart from faith, then what if I really don’t have faith and I’m deluding myself?